One of indie-rock's most talked-about new bands of the year, Car Seat Headrest did not even have copies of its acclaimed new record in stores until last Friday. That's because the first 50,000 or so copies of the LP had to be destroyed after a legal rift with Ric Ocasek.
"I can't blame him for wanting to maintain control of his property," Car Seat Headrest's driving force Will Toledo said of the Cars frontman. "I just wish it had been easier to contact him in the first place."
A Virginia-reared, Seattle-based recent college grad who named his band after his first audience member — more on that later — Toledo writes a lot of free-association type of songs that incorporate lyrical left-turns and unpredictable moments. Twin Cities fans will get all those changeups thrown at them Monday when the band lands at the Triple Rock, following a much-ballyhooed appearance at Chicago's Pitchfork Music Fest.
One of those twisty-turvy moments found Toledo channeling a few bars of the Cars' hit "Just What I Needed" in an original song called "Not What I Needed." It wasn't a "sample" in the hip-hop sense, but Car Seat Headrest's new label Matador Records still needed to (and failed to) get that sort of clearance from Ocasek's publishing company. Toledo had to re-record the tune without the Cars snippet, and Matador had to re-press the record once he did.
"I thought it was just a fun thing to throw in, something that happened while I was writing the song," Toledo recounted. "If somebody had told me, 'You can't do that,' I would've taken it out, which I did in the end. But that conversation didn't happen until the very last minute."
The good news is that the record in question has been available online since May and already stands up as one of the best rock albums of the year.
Titled "Teens of Denial," it weaves between spazzy, off-kilter, Pavement-style sonic play to more straight-ahead Guided by Voices-style power-pop while Toledo as a singer/songwriter comes across like a manic-depressive version of the Kinks' Ray Davies or Jonathan Richman.
Only 23, Toledo grew up in an upper-middle-class neighborhood in northern Virginia, which he said "is mostly made up of people who work in Washington, D.C., so there isn't really any local culture." After graduating from the College of William and Mary in Williamsburg, he said, "There wasn't really anything to keep me in Virginia — especially not much of a music scene to work in, which is what I knew I wanted to do."