
People have been complaining about how sports are officiated for as long as there have been sports. In the first footrace at the Olympic Games nearly 3,000 years ago, one can imagine angry spectators throwing stones at some poor timekeeper.
The voices have grown louder and angrier, it seems, in recent years. Maybe officiating is getting worse? Maybe (probably) we're more sensitive to missed calls because high-definition TV and slow-motion replays give us a better look, in many cases, than the officials? Maybe the magnitude of controversial calls, given the millions (and in some cases billions) at stake gives them more impact and makes them seem more pervasive?
Whatever the case, the anger seems directed at two main sources: Balls and strikes in MLB games (where that little box makes us all instant umpires); and pretty much any flag that comes out during an NFL game. The former is a problem, but beyond some momentum for "robot umps" it feels mostly like background noise in baseball. Nobody rational would say the work of home plate umpires is ruining the sport.
In the NFL, however, there is an increasing sense that the rules and how they are enforced — including the addition of reviewable pass interference this year — is tainting the product. Even Tom Brady, who tends to have the most milquetoast opinions, took a break from being a robot to tweet during a Thursday Night game earlier this year, "Too many penalties. Just let us play!!!"
It seems to be a trend that the rage increases during primetime games, when everyone watching football has just one option. And it felt like it reached a fever pitch Monday during the Packers' larcenous 23-22 victory over Detroit.
The gifts to the Lambeau faithful are too numerous to run through one by one, but the biggest complaints were about two phantom illegal hands to the face calls that significantly hindered the Lions. What's most important is that after the game, even those with skin in the game — including the mild-mannered Tony Dungy! — were jumping into the fray to get in their $.02.
Former Packer Desmond Howard was the most aggressive, insinuating that the game was fixed.