Kate Hebel added a burglar alarm to her Macalester-Groveland home decades ago with her father's words ringing in her ears: "Locks only keep the honest people honest."
She has dutifully paid the $28 annual fee St. Paul charges people with alarm systems. But when she saw the city planned to more than double it to $58, she was flabbergasted. She wrote to city leaders, saying they would dissuade homeowners from adding security equipment that makes the city safer.
After receiving dozens of similar messages over the past month, the City Council opted for a lesser annual fee increase, pushing to instead make people pay more for false alarms.
Council Members Dai Thao and Dan Bostrom, who have raised different concerns about increasing alarm owners' costs, voted against the ordinance setting the annual fee at $38.
More than 98 percent of alarm calls in St. Paul last year were false or unfounded and those calls take up a lot of police time and resources, Deputy Police Chief Paul Iovino said last month. The city has not increased its alarm fee in more than a decade, Iovino said, and staff worked to come up with "as balanced an approach as we could."
Francesca Stirpe was one of many residents who said the city's initial proposal did not strike the right balance. Those who are causing the false alarms should pay even more, said Stirpe, who lives in the Western Hazel Park neighborhood on St. Paul's East Side.
"That means people need to be on their A game," she said, and be responsible for their system.
Residents and businesses with alarm systems have been allowed two free false alarms a year before paying $25 for the third and $50 for the fourth. The penalties continued to grow from there.