The 29 applicants for St. Paul city attorney made an impressive group.
They included city, county and assistant county attorneys, trial specialists, a state appeals director and a military lawyer. Résumés showed an average of 14 years legal experience.
Yet Mayor Chris Coleman interviewed just one candidate and then hired him: Samuel Clark, a 31-year-old congressional aide with two years in private practice, whose longest job since law school was performing constituent service as state director for Sen. Amy Klobuchar.
"I absolutely think he's the best choice," Coleman said last week. "If there was a question in my mind, I wouldn't have hired him."
At a time when the city attorney's office has been called on to negotiate settlements in several high-profile cases, and in the wake of Coleman's surprise appointment of former City Council President Kathy Lantry for Public Works director, the choice raises questions about the importance of political ties and to what degree that works against candidates with stronger résumés but fewer party credentials.
Coleman, Klobuchar and Lantry are all DFLers.
"I think the citizens of St. Paul deserve something better," said Jeremy Schroeder, executive director of Common Cause Minnesota. "It begs the question of 'What was the mayor looking for?' "
"We are against a lot of the cronyism that is taking place in St. Paul," said Trahern Crews, spokesman for the St. Paul Green Party and a First Ward City Council candidate.