Oil spill in North Dakota is Keystone pipeline's 2nd in 2 years

November 1, 2019 at 1:55AM
Affected land from a Keystone oil pipeline leak near Edinburg, N.D.
This Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2019 photo provided by the North Dakota Department of Environmental Quality shows affected land from a Keystone oil pipeline leak near Edinburg, North Dakota. Regulators said TC Energy's Keystone pipeline leaked an estimated 383,000 gallons of oil in northeastern North Dakota, though the cause was still under investigation. (North Dakota Department of Environmental Quality/Taylor DeVries) ORG XMIT: MER0613937b64e3da477f4693fa9c820 (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

An oil spill on the Key­stone pipe­line in north­east­ern North Da­ko­ta this week is the se­cond sig­nifi­cant leak in two years on a crude oil pipe­line that op­ened less than a dec­ade ago.

The Key­stone pipe­line, which trans­ports oil from Al­ber­ta to the Midwest, ap­pears to have rup­tured on Tues­day and has since spilled an estimated 383,000 gal­lons of crude near the town of Edinburg, ac­cord­ing to the North Da­ko­ta Department of En­vi­ron­men­tal Quality.

The Cal­ga­ry-based com­pany that op­er­ates the pipe­line, TC Energy, said in a state­ment that the leak has af­fect­ed a­bout 22,500 square feet of land, or a­bout a half-acre. The com­pany said it's work­ing to dis­cover the leak's cause, as well as cleaning up the spill and repairing the pipeline.

State en­vi­ron­men­tal regu­la­tors say the spill en­croached on wet­lands a­bout 3 miles out­side of Edinburg, which is a­bout 70 miles north­west of Grand Forks.

In No­vem­ber 2017, the Key­stone pipe­line ruptured near Am­herst, S.D., spill­ing 407,000 gal­lons of oil, though initial estimates pegged the leak at 210,000 gallons.

The prob­able cause of that spill was a "fa­tigue crack" from me­chan­i­cal dam­age dur­ing the pipe­line's con­struc­tion, the National Transportation Safety Board con­clud­ed last year. A metal-tracked ve­hi­cle like­ly caused the crack, which grew over time un­til the pipe­line rup­tured.

"It's a valid ques­tion, two cracks on a fair­ly new pipe­line — geez what's going on?" said Rich­ard Kuprewicz, pres­i­dent of Accufacts, a Wash­ing­ton state-based pipe­line safe­ty con­sult­ing firm.

Still, he cau­tioned that "age is not a pre­dic­tor of pipe­line fail­ure. I have seen new pipe­lines that have re­al­ly been abused and I have seen old pipe­lines that look like new."

The Key­stone pipe­line is one of three large trans­na­tion­al pipe­line sys­tems that trans­port a par­tic­u­lar­ly thick crude from Al­ber­ta's oil sands, also called tar sands. The larg­est such sys­tem is run by Cal­ga­ry-based En­bridge, and its main cor­ri­dor of pipelines runs through north­ern Min­ne­so­ta to Su­pe­ri­or, Wis.

En­bridge is in the midst of a years­long bat­tle to build a new pipe­line to re­place its ex­ist­ing Line 3, which is ag­ing, cor­rod­ing and op­er­at­ing at only 51% ca­pac­i­ty. Min­ne­so­ta pub­lic utili­ties regu­la­tors ap­proved new Line 3 last year. But the pipe­line — fierce­ly op­posed by en­vi­ron­men­tal groups and some Ojib­we tribes — is still wait­ing for oth­er per­mits.

The Key­stone pipe­line, which fer­ries oil to ter­mi­nals in Oklahoma and southern Il­li­nois, op­ened in 2010. TC Energy is try­ing to ex­pand the Key­stone sys­tem with its con­tro­ver­sial Key­stone XL pipe­line, which would run from Al­ber­ta through Mon­tan­a and South Da­ko­ta to Steele City, Neb.This week's North Da­ko­ta leak would rank in the Top 10 larg­est U.S. on­shore oil spills since 2010. In that year, an En­bridge pipe­line rup­tured in south­west­ern Mich­i­gan, spill­ing 834,000 gal­lons of Ca­na­di­an crude. En­bridge's last ma­jor spill in Min­ne­so­ta was in 2002 when Line 3 failed near Cohasset, re­leas­ing 252,000 gal­lons of oil.

Mike Hughlett • 612-673-7003

about the writer

about the writer

Mike Hughlett

Reporter

Mike Hughlett covers energy and other topics for the Star Tribune, where he has worked since 2010. Before that he was a reporter at newspapers in Chicago, St. Paul, New Orleans and Duluth.

See More

More from Business

card image

Passenger volume at Rochester International Airport is down nearly 50% since the start of the pandemic as travelers migrate to MSP for cheaper flights without layovers.

card image