Lord help me! One of the last things that Minnesota needs is another county! I couldn't believe it when I read that there is consideration of splitting St. Louis County in two (Minnesota section, March 4).
Let's consider a couple things: First, Arizona, with a larger size and greater population, has 15 counties and Minnesota has 87. Second, there are similarities in population distribution — heavy concentration in a few metropolitan areas and large sparsely populated stretches. Another comparison: St. Louis County's 7,000 square miles pales in comparison to Arizona's largest county, Coconino, with 18,661 square miles, larger than nine of the smallest states. It doesn't take a genius to conclude that having 87 sets of county government is not as fiscally prudent as having 15. That said, I would suggest that Minnesota consider consolidating counties and eliminating the duplication of county government instead of adding to the problem.
Loren Berg, Rio Verde, Ariz.
MNLARS
This didn't have to be a fiasco; just follow rules of thumb
It seems obvious that the folks who planned the Minnesota Licensing and Registration System upgrade did not have adequate experience in large software development projects ("Lawmakers roll out plans to repair MNLARS system," March 7). Otherwise, they would know that the rule of thumb is to take the best estimates from your software engineers, then double it. If it's a particularly large project — say, more than $10 million — you may need to triple it. If a government agency is involved, add another 50 percent. Take that to the boss or the Legislature for funding and save a lot of embarrassing hassle later.
You also need to have a good answer as to why this would be cheaper than licensing a proven Real-ID-capable registration system from one of the other 49 states and having your crew change all the names in the source code to "Minnesota."
I know this oversimplifies things, perhaps unreasonably, but the history of large software system deployments contains no track record of reliability when it comes to actual costs and delivery schedules. When are we going to understand this and plan for it before the project begins?
Dennis Fazio, Minneapolis
The writer is a former computer designer and internet services executive.
• • •
Given the mess made of MNLARS, I don't think the state stands a chance against vote-hacking.