By announcing the choice of a new superintendent before fully vetting him, the Minneapolis school board now finds itself in an embarrassing spot — one that raises disturbing questions about the search and hiring process.
Without further delay, the board should cut its losses, break off contract talks with Sergio Paez for good and restart the selection process.
Early last week, the board announced that Paez, the former superintendent in Holyoke, Mass., would become the district's next top administrator. He got the nod following a 10-month national search conducted by a consultant, as well as panel discussions, public interviews and community forums with three finalists.
But just 48 hours after the announcement, a report by the Disability Law Center alleged that students in a Holyoke special education program were abused by school staff members while Paez was superintendent. The nonprofit advocacy group described excessive use of restraints and said students were "thrown to the floor and slapped."
Under Massachusetts law, physical restraint can be used as a last resort and only when a student's behavior poses a serious threat to the student or someone else. The school did not report the restraints or their related injuries to the state Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, as required by statute, the report alleges.
Last week, Paez told the Star Tribune that he was aware of the allegations and that his office had investigated and found no student neglect. "The state was on top of it. I was on top of it, and that's the end," he said.
But that wasn't the end. Now Massachusetts education officials are investigating the incidents. And Hampden County District Attorney Anthony Gulluni has launched a criminal investigation.
That series of events casts a shadow on Minneapolis school leaders, because they announced Paez as their pick and then said they'd do a site visit in Holyoke before finalizing his contract. Last week, the Star Tribune Editorial Board asked why that visit wasn't done before the announcement.