REVIEW: 'The Hamlet Fire: A Tragic Story of Cheap Food, Cheap Government, and Cheap Lives,' by Bryant Simon

NONFICTION: A deep analysis of the root causes of a fire at a North Carolina chicken processing plant that killed 25 workers.

August 25, 2017 at 3:01PM
Bryant Simon Photo by Glennis London Pagano
Bryant Simon Photo by Glennis London Pagano (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

On Sept. 3, 1991, workers at Imperial Food Products in the small town of Hamlet, N.C., heard a loud bang and then a hissing sound, as if a missile had just been launched inside the facility.

Moments later, a wall of flames swept through the decrepit brick chicken processing plant, which had never been inspected in its 11 years of operation. Workers who rushed to the emergency exits found they had been padlocked from the outside. Twenty-five workers, many of them single mothers, died behind the locked doors.

Journalists trying to piece together what happened that day focused on a string of tragic errors. The locked exits. The sprinkler system that failed. And the faulty hydraulic hose that sprayed flammable fluids in every direction, igniting the walls and ceiling.

Yet these accounts obscure the deeper economic and political roots of the tragedy in Hamlet, still the largest industrial accident in North Carolina history.

As Temple University history Prof. Bryant Simon argues in his prodigiously researched and penetrating analysis, "The Hamlet Fire," the blaze was the product of four decades of deregulation in the poultry industry, driven by Americans' insatiable appetite for cheap consumer goods.

"Again and again, those with power valued cheap food, cheap government and cheap lives over … strong oversight and regulation," he writes.

Simon, who spent six years researching his book, draws a direct line between the fire in Hamlet and the disappearance of railroad and industrial jobs. The dislocations turned this once bustling freight rail hub, with stable and secure jobs, into a rural backwater. The weakened labor market made it possible for unscrupulous companies such as Imperial Food Products to command more control over workers, silencing those who complained of low pay and hazardous working conditions.

Like thousands of other manufacturers that relocated to the South in the 1980s, Imperial Food Products exploited the region's lax enforcement of workplace safety laws.

Even though the plant caught fire three times between 1980 and 1987, no safety inspector had ever set foot in the factory. Complaints of maggots and lice were ignored by the state's workplace agency. And when investigators went digging for the plant's Labor Department records after the fire, they came up empty. Technically, Imperial Food Products was not even authorized to be in business.

Sadly, there is little that is unique about the Hamlet fire. The tragedy bears striking similarities to a series of horrifying industrial disasters in recent years. In 2013, a garment factory near Dhaka, Bangladesh, collapsed, killing more than 1,100 workers. That same year, a fire tore through a poultry processing plant in northeast China, killing 120 people. As Simon notes, each of these tragedies occurred in remote areas where the factories could operate without interference from labor groups or government regulators.

Chris Serres is a Star Tribune reporter. 612-673-4308

The Hamlet Fire
By: Bryant Simon.
The New Press, 303 pages, $26.95.

September 4, 1991 Comforting Hug - Manzelle Henderson, facing earner, a worker at Imperial Food Products in Hamlet. N.C., gets a comforting hug from a friend outside the plant Wednesday, after she arrived to pick up her pay check. Twenty five workers died end 49 were injured during a fire at the plant on Tuesday. September 5, 1991 September 11, 1991 Chuck Burton, AP Laserphoto
Manzelle Henderson, a worker at Imperial Food Products in Hamlet, N.C., was comforted outside the chicken processing plant after a fatal 1991 fire. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
"The Hamlet Fire," by Bryant Simon
“The Hamlet Fire,” by Bryant Simon (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Chris Serres

Reporter

Chris Serres is a staff writer for the Star Tribune who covers social services.

See More