In the wake of the latest viral video where two men were apparently arrested for nothing more than "waiting for a friend while black," Starbucks has announced that it will close all its U.S. stores on May 29 so that nearly 175,000 of its employees can undergo a "training program designed to address implicit bias."
It is a nice gesture, but the problem is not merely implicit bias; it is racism. And it is not going to be addressed by more training and education from diversity experts.
It requires accountability.
When we speak of implicit bias, we are referring to what psychologists characterize as cognitive "mind bugs," or unconscious stereotypes. We manifest implicit bias without knowing it — through averting our eyes or smiling less at a person of color.
Implicit bias is real and demands our concern, but it should not be used to explain every racial incident.
The problem with elevating implicit bias into a master narrative for understanding race relations is that it provides us with too easy an out and blinds us to the persistence of the harsher realities of racism. By definition, implicit bias is beyond our conscious control, so we do not need to feel responsible for it. Moreover, everybody has it; and if everybody is to blame, then nobody is ever held accountable.
Coming back to the Starbucks case: There were two distinct but related problems with this incident. First, why did the Starbucks employee feel compelled to call police to come remove two men from the store for "trespassing" when they were not being disruptive and had explained they were waiting for a friend? Second, why did the police respond with massive force (I counted seven officers in the video), handcuff the two men and then arrest them?
There is nothing "implicit" about the bias in these actions. The other patrons in the video did not need "implicit-bias training" to see these actions for what they were: racism. Racism on the part of the employee who called the police, and racism on the part of the police who responded in an unjustifiably aggressive and officious manner.