Target's stock had the best day in its history on Wednesday, rising more than 20% after the mass retailer posted higher-than-expected sales and profits that erased lingering doubts about the strength of its business.
"In the past, there were some holes you could point to in the Target story," said Brian Yarbrough, an analyst with Edward Jones. "But today, there's really no holes. They've executed. They're proving that stores are still important."
Target's margins have been "squishy" in the past, squeezed by price cuts to compete with Walmart and Amazon and the higher costs to fulfill online orders, Yarbrough said. But on Wednesday, Target posted its first quarterly increase in gross margin rate in nearly three years and raised its overall profit outlook for the year.
Target also showed that consumers are still interested in coming to its stores and are flocking to its same-day services of in-store pickup, curbside pickup and home delivery via Shipt, which have doubled in sales volume in the last year.
The solid metrics provided more proof points to Wall Street, allaying the fear that Target is going to be "another victim of Amazon," Yarbrough added.
Target's shares closed at $103. It was the first time shares were over $100 since the early 1980s when the company name was Dayton Hudson Corp. The stock has split three times since then.
It was the latest signal that investors, who were initially skeptical, have bought into the stores-focused turnaround plan of CEO Brian Cornell, who marked five years in the job this month.
Cornell has guided the company on a multiyear path to reinvigorate its business through remodeling hundreds of stores and launching dozens of new private-label brands across apparel, home decor, cleaning supplies and electronics, while retiring older ones. The company also has been opening about 30 small-format stores a year near college campuses and in urban areas and has rolled out curbside pickup and same-day delivery across the country.