
The burger: I hesitate to declare that the cheeseburger at the Draft Horse is all about the bun, because that wouldn't do justice to several other top-notch components.
But dang, that bun. Flaxen in color and rising to an impressive crown, it's baked next door at one of the state's great craft operations, Baker's Field Flour & Bread. Truly, it's something else.
"It's made with local wheat that's milled here, right down the hall," said chef John Lambe. "It's got a sweetness to it, and while it's nice and soft in the center, it more than stands up to the rest of the burger, and it holds it all together."
Lambe improves upon a good thing with a two-step finishing process. First, he toasts the buns in the oven ("That steams them up and softens them, in a fresh-out-of-the-oven kind of way," he said), then he butters the insides and introduces them to the flat-top stove. "That gives them a good crunch, and a little bit of caramelization," he said. "That toastiness also helps hold the aioli, and the juices from the patty."
The menu bills that rich aioli as a "special sauce," a fitting name. It's fortified with the kitchen's dreamy house-made pickles (more on those in a moment), chopped green onions and a splash of the house-made hot sauce. Because, of course Lambe and his crew make their own hot sauce. "I just saw some jalapeños at the farmers market," he said.
The patty? Superb, with a juicy, intensely beefy bite that comes courtesy of Peterson Craftsman Meats in Osceola, Wis.
"It's a fine grind, and a flavorful 80/20 blend," he said, referring to the beef's meat/fat ratio. "They dry age it for 21 days before they grind it, and it's an outstanding, flavorful beef." It sure is. Lambe forms it into patties that are thicker than the prevailing diner style but thinner than a steakhouse-inspired burger. Seasoning is just salt and pepper (with beef this good, nothing more is required) when the patty hits the stove, and the cheese is unadulterated American.
"We debated about that," said Lambe. "I like Cheddar on a burger, and we have lots of great Cheddar cheeses. But American melts to the right consistency, and there's just something about American that pulls on your heartstrings, and binds the whole burger together."