In response to my column highlighting amusing errors, a reader questioned my emphasis on proper grammar.
"I enjoy reading your column," he wrote, "and I do try to write succinctly. However, in this day and age and with the amount of correspondence there is to read, it seems, trying to get a point across is more important than proper grammar.
"Granted, it is better to write clearly, but sometimes the choice of words, although they may not be exactly correct, does anyone stop to evaluate the writer! An authoritative person's writing wouldn't be dismissed just because their sentence structure does not have the correct noun, verb, adjective being used correctly. Just my opinion!"
It's an opinion I hear often.
Curious about how students in the "Communication in a Technical Environment" class I teach at the University of Minnesota would respond, I shared my reader's message with them. Although they expressed some sympathy for his position, they also talked about credibility and how attention to the rules of language encourages clarity in thought and expression. One student pointed out that my reader's argument might have been more convincing if it had been better written.
With this debate in mind, I offer my top 10 reasons for using proper grammar:
1. Grammatical errors are distracting.
2. Grammatical errors interfere with clarity.