The lingering uncertainty over Phil Hughes' role on the Twins is finally over. There isn't one.
The veteran righthander, who hoped to capture a spot in the starting rotation during spring training, then tried to fill a vague, undefined bullpen role when that didn't work, was designated for assignment following Monday's game, a reluctant acknowledgement by the Twins that they can wait no longer to figure out how to use him.
"When we moved him to the pen, we were looking for opportunities to have him work his way back. And it became challenging," Twins manager Paul Molitor said after breaking the news, along with Chief Baseball Officer Derek Falvey and General Manager Thad Levine, to the 31-year-old. "We played so many close games, I haven't had a big opportunity [to use him], and I apologized to him for that."
The Twins filled Hughes' roster spot by recalling outfielder Ryan LaMarre from Class AAA Rochester. LaMarre hit .324 with three RBI in two earlier stints with the Twins, and hit .371 at Rochester.
Cutting ties with Hughes, who received Cy Young Award votes for his strong first season with the Twins in 2014, is an uncharacteristically costly move for the team.
With a guaranteed salary of $13.2 million, Hughes earns more than any Twin except Joe Mauer ($23 million) and Ervin Santana ($13.5 million) — and he is guaranteed $13.2 million next year, too, under a five-year, $58 million contract extension he signed before the 2015 season. Molitor said Falvey and Levine discussed the move with Twins owner Jim Pohlad.
Hughes pitched 209⅓ innings in 2014, after signing as a free agent from the Yankees, and he posted a 3.52 ERA while famously declining an opportunity to pitch on the season's final day to record one out and collect a $500,000 incentive for reaching 210 innings.
Thanks in large part to injuries, however, Hughes has pitched only 280 innings in the four seasons since. He suffered a back injury, fractured a femur, and in 2016 underwent surgery to treat thoracic outlet syndrome — a condition in which the arteries in his pitching shoulder were compressed by his ribs and collarbone — then had another surgery a year later to address a recurrence of his symptoms.