This week the U.S. women's national team takes on Germany, France and England in the SheBelieves Cup, a yearly tournament that includes four of the world's best teams. After the men's abject failure to qualify for the World Cup, the women are on guard against a failure of their own. This tournament will be key in establishing the team that will go into World Cup qualifying this fall. The U.S. is still the top-ranked team in the world, but head coach Jill Ellis still has some question marks to address, especially on defense.
In 2015, the team's defense was the bedrock of the all-conquering World Cup performance. The U.S. allowed just one goal in the group stage, then swept through the knockout round without allowing a goal until leading 4-0 in the finals. Goalkeeper Hope Solo and center backs Becky Sauerbrunn and Julie Ertz (then Julie Johnston) were the key to letting the offense roam free.
In the two years since, Solo retired and Ertz moved up to a role in the center of midfield. Last year in the SheBelieves Cup, Ellis' solution to this change was to play with three central defenders at the back. That experiment ended when France smashed the U.S. 3-0 for its worst loss in a decade.
The team has switched back to a traditional back four, and is trying to figure out who fits where. That task will be more complicated in this tournament, as Sauerbrunn is out with a foot injury.
The key may be in goal, where Chicago Red Stars keeper Alyssa Naeher has been first choice to try to fill Solo's legendary gloves. Naeher has started all but a few games, but has not excelled. Veteran Ashlyn Harris has started the games that Naeher hasn't. Ellis may choose to rotate the two in the hopes of creating strength in depth.
North Carolina Courage center back Abby Dahlkemper has emerged as Sauerbrunn's new central-defense partner. But the pair has been uneven at best — and Sauerbrunn's absence will rob the two of a chance to build a rapport on the big stage.
At fullback, the U.S. has more options, with such veterans as Megan Klingenberg and Kelley O'Hara still in the running. Dahlkemper's North Carolina teammate Taylor Smith and Chicago's Casey Short were regular choices throughout 2017. Ellis will be using these high-pressure games to try to find four players who work well together.
This tournament will be a test of the United States' ability to control the tempo and flow of the game, which starts by being solid on defense. Not every team in the world is talented enough to press the United States and hit on the counter-attack, but all three of their opponents in this tournament can do so. It led to the Americans finishing last in the four-team tournament last year. This year's edition, which begins Thursday with the United States playing Germany, is a chance to improve.