This is my first Christmas without my dad, who passed away in April after a battle with cancer. It was a difficult time, and one thing that helped was messages from friends.
One friend, who lost his own father in 2018, wrote that, however painful it was, children burying their parents is the "natural" way of things.
I deeply appreciate what my friend was trying to say. But it just isn't true.
Just north of St. Peter on County Road 20 is Green Lawn Cemetery. In it, you'll find the grave of Thomas Pettijohn, who died in 1897, at age 72, and his wife, Charity, who had died, at age 54, in 1879. What is striking are the other names on the family grave — Lydia, who had died in 1863, less than a year after her birth; Mary, who had died the same year, age 9; Thomas, who had died before his first birthday in 1869; Amos, who had died the following year, also less than 1 year old, and William, who had died, age 3, in 1878. Thomas and Charity buried five of their children before the children had reached their 10th birthdays.
Such tragedies were commonplace only a few generations ago. Nor were they confined to obscure settlers like the Pettijohns. Two of Charles Darwin's children — Mary Eleanor and Charles — died before their second birthdays. Another daughter, Annie, died at age 10 in 1851.
Nor did the frequency of such losses lessen the pain they caused. Of Annie's death, Darwin wrote, "We have lost the joy of the household, and the solace of our old age. ... Oh that she could now know how deeply, how tenderly we do still and shall ever love her dear joyous face."
The facts are that for most of human history the "natural" way of things was for parents to bury children. Nowadays, as my friend suggests, such sorrows are rare tragedies. The numbers tell the story. In 1860, the share of the global population that died in the first five years of life was 41%. In 2017, it was 4%.
In the U.S., in 1900, 1 child in every 4 died before his or her fifth birthday. Today it is 1 out of 167.