The Portland Thorns are the defending National Women's Soccer League (NWSL) champions. Providence Park, the home of both the Thorns and the Timbers of MLS, will be packed to the rafters yet again when the Timbers begin their home season April 15, providing a big-game feel that can't be matched anywhere else in the women's soccer world. In this, the sixth year of the NWSL, why can't there be more teams like the Thorns?
Portland has been extremely successful on the field, with two league championships and one Supporters' Shield. But the focus tends to be on the ever-filled bleachers at Thorns' home games. If you take Portland out of the equation, the NWSL as a whole averaged about 3,600 fans per game last season. Portland, meanwhile, averaged 17,653.
Outside of Portland, the league has struggled to attract fans, sponsors and media coverage. Two founding teams folded last winter. While U.S. Soccer supports the league and pays the salaries of the national-team players, if the NWSL is going to grow and thrive, it needs more teams like the Thorns.
The prime driver for Portland's success is its ownership situation. When the league launched in 2013, every MLS team got a chance at starting a new women's franchise. The only one who took the offer was Timbers owner Merritt Paulson, who decided that it was not only important to start a women's team, but to do it right.
The Thorns' players get the same treatment as the Timbers. Both teams' logos adorn the outside of Providence Park. Thorns players aren't second-class citizens in the Rose City soccer setup. Since the two teams share staff and facilities, they have a built-in advantage that the league's independent teams can't match.
That said, Houston, Orlando and Utah are all in the same MLS-owned situation, and yet there's only one Portland (Utah is a new team this year, so it remains to be seen how Utahans react to the squad). Houston and Orlando both have downtown stadiums like Portland, and it's hard to argue that the Pacific Northwest has soccer culture that Orlando and Houston don't have. Unless the Thorns have some magic hipster attraction to Portlandians, or Portland somehow has a more egalitarian ticket-buying public than the rest of the NWSL cities, it's hard to see what the Thorns have that no one else has.
Paulson has repeatedly said that there's no "magic fairy dust" causing the Thorns' success. The quest now, for the rest of America, is to replicate it. The league needs more potential owners to step up, as Paulson did, and use their resources to help keep the NWSL from becoming a second-class league. Plenty of people involved with soccer in America — MLS owners or others — have the resources and expertise to replicate what is going on in Portland. The challenge for the NWSL now is getting those potential owners to care.
SOCCER SHORT TAKES