Fifth grade wasn't my best year in school. I was in excellent standing with my teachers, but less so with my peers, the latter perhaps related to the former. Still, the adults encouraged me not to shy away, so I tried to join in.
One opportunity was an informal playground game we called — well, I'll shorten the name to smear: basically rugby without the gentility. It was, strictly speaking, against the rules, and it was played nearly every day.
Once when I was at the bottom of the pile, one of the rougher kids decided to jump on while the rest were peeling off. The impact slightly hyperextended my elbow.
By the end of the day, it was still hurting, so I went to the principal's office to tattle on the other kid for his breach of sportsmanship.
The principal eyed me for few seconds, then said, simply, "You aren't supposed to play smear."
I have no doubt that if I'd been truly injured, he would have undertaken whatever action was necessary. But at that moment, I felt betrayed, wondering what my star-pupil status was good for if not the redress of injustice.
But I also began to realize, in ways I can better articulate now than I could then, that he was teaching me a lesson by letting me arrive at it myself. Several lessons, actually. First, that others' uncensured participation in a questionable activity does not confer absolution for joining in. Second, that actions have consequences that must be accepted and ought be understood. Third, that one should worry more about one's own behavior than that of others. As I've moved through life, these lessons have never lost their pertinence.
I'd first met Garry Purvis a few years before the playground incident, when I was in first grade and he was welcoming me to his elementary school. We'd just moved to Kasson-Mantorville, one of the many pairs of municipalities in Minnesota that are known as one because they share a school district. I remember Garry as seeming mirthful and fun, key criteria in any kid's estimation. My duly attentive mom was impressed, too, but noticed that his gait was a bit tipsy, and wasn't sure what to make of that.