Best picture: Which of the eight contenders should win?

January 14, 2016 at 5:23PM

"The Revenant" is gaining steam after its big Golden Globes win, but there are other top contenders in the best film race. Here's a look at what will play into each movie's favor, and what's working against them. Plus, our critic's original star rating.

The Big Short

The story: A few financial savants foresee the housing crisis and take on the big banks.

In its favor: With humor and layman's language, it breaks down a complex subject into understandable bites, stoking a fine sense of outrage.

Then again: We're put in the position of rooting for guys who make millions off others' misery.

Bridge of Spies

The story: A New York lawyer is recruited to represent a Soviet spy in this true-life Cold War tale.

In its favor: Three words: Spielberg and Hanks. Plus two more: Mark Rylance.

Then again: It wears its square all-Americanism on its sleeve. And Amy Ryan is wasted as the long-suffering wife of cliché.

Brooklyn

The story: A young Irishwoman finds a new life in America, even as the old sod beckons.

In its favor: Saoirse Ronan is luminous as Eilis, and her central dilemma makes for wrenching drama.

Then again: The tender, old-fashioned style might strike some as too saccharine.

Mad Max: Fury Road

The story: Drifter Max Rockatansky joins forces with the rebel Furiosa in post-apocalyptic Australia.

In its favor: Fueled on pure adrenaline, it's what fast and furious really look like. The rare action movie that passes the Bechdel Test.

Then again: It's been compared to a glorified video game.

The Martian

The story: An astronaut/botanist left for dead on Mars must find a way to stay alive.

In its favor: Cheeky and tense in equal measure, it gives scientists the chance to bask in a heroic glow.

Then again: Human emotion is in as short supply on the Red Planet as water and oxygen.

The Revenant

The story: A frontiersman seeks revenge after a brutal bear mauling.

In its favor: A feral, tour de force performance by Leonardo DiCaprio, epic cinematography and the golden pedigree of "Birdman" director Alejandro González Iñárritu.

Then again: Did we mention the bear? It's a harrowing and unrelentingly grim journey.

Room

The story: A young woman raises her son in the tiny shed where they are kept captive.

In its favor: Brie Larson and the wondrous young Jacob Tremblay are achingly believable.

Then again: The first act is so uncomfortably claustrophobic that you might not stick around for the denouement.

Spotlight

The story: The Boston Globe uncovers systematic abuse and coverup by the Catholic Church.

In its favor: This "All the President's Men" for a new generation makes digging through dusty files seem urgent and thrilling.

Then again: It's resolutely unglamorous, kinda like journalists themselves.

Leonardo DiCaprio in "The Revenant."
Leonardo DiCaprio in "The Revenant." (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Cynthia Dickison

Designer-Features

Cynthia Dickison is a features designer. She is a St. Paul native and graduate of the University of Minnesota. She has worked at the Star Tribune since 1978, starting on the copy desk. Dickison has worked in every department — news, sports, features, even a short stint on the business cover.

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More
FILE -- A rent deposit slot at an apartment complex in Tucker, Ga., on July 21, 2020. As an eviction crisis has seemed increasingly likely this summer, everyone in the housing market has made the same plea to Washington: Send money — lots of it — that would keep renters in their homes and landlords afloat. (Melissa Golden/The New York Times) ORG XMIT: XNYT58
Melissa Golden/The New York Times

It’s too soon to tell how much the immigration crackdown is to blame.