Breaking up with diet soda? Here are 10 aspartame-free alternatives

No matter what you're drinking, moderation is key.

By Melissa Clark

The New York Times
July 19, 2023 at 12:30PM
Diet soda fans would need to drink 24 cans a day to put them in danger zone. (J. David Ake, Associated Press file/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The World Health Organization declared last week that the artificial sweetener aspartame is "possibly carcinogenic to humans." But you'd have to chug quite a bit of diet soda to enter the danger zone.

Its new guidance for safe consumption is 40 milligrams of aspartame per kilogram of body weight, meaning that a diet cola fan weighing 150 pounds could drink as many as 24 cans a day. Still, the news may give the jitters to diet drink die-hards. If you're ready to swear off the stuff, or cut down, here are 10 aspartame-free alternatives.

Iced tea: It doesn't look or exactly taste like diet cola, and it's not even fizzy. But the tannins in iced tea mimic some of that carefully honed Diet Coke complexity, and the caffeine will keep you from dropping off at your desk. Just go easy on the sugar.

Kombucha: Lightly caffeinated and made from fermented black or green tea, it's gently effervescent, judiciously sweet and may even be good for your gut microbiome — or whatever microbiome your diet drink habit has left you with.

Sparkling water: It fizzes and is available in a can, which gives you that same satisfying hiss-snap when you crack it open.

Seltzer and bitters: A bar staple for many pregnant women and teetotalers, it's zippy, sort of sophisticated and very satisfying.

Pomegranate juice and club soda: This concoction hits the same bright and tangy notes as an icy Diet Coke, and even better, the foam is a perky pink.

Prosecco: True, alcohol is listed by the WHO as clearly carcinogenic, perhaps even in modest amounts. And prosecco is hardly low-calorie. But hey, pick your poison.

Shrubs: Shrubs are a sort of locavore-hipster home brew made from fruit-infused vinegar and bubbly water. Bonus: They come in farm-to-table flavors like rhubarb-beet and turmeric-cucumber.

DIY Cola: In his book "Homemade Soda," Andrew Schloss offers a recipe for "natural cola" made from fresh and dried citrus zest, coriander, nutmeg and Kitchen Bouquet browning sauce, adding optional gum arabic for "mouthfeel." Carbonate it with a CO2 siphon for the fluffiest froth. For hard-core enthusiasts only.

Sugared soft drinks: These may be the versions you originally fell in love with. It may be tempting to get back in touch with your ex, but given the dietary perils of too much sugar or corn syrup, keep your hookups occasional.

Water: Here's the no-brainer solution: sugarless, easy to find and free. But even water carries risks. Drinking more than a quart or so per hour, particularly if you're doing something strenuous, can cause a dangerous electrolyte imbalance.

about the writer

Melissa Clark