Eyebrows were raised across baseball when the Twins signed shortstop Carlos Correa to a three-year, $105.3 million contract during the offseason.
Even with Correa's ability to opt out after each of the first two seasons, it appeared to be a win for both sides. The Twins added an elite player to the lineup while allowing prospect Royce Lewis to rebound following knee surgery. Unfortunately for the Twins, Lewis injured his knee again.
Correa gets $35.1 million — the fifth-highest salary in baseball this season — with the option of re-entering the market after the season and getting more.
Unfortunately for the Twins, they are not getting $35.1 million of production out of Correa. If the Twins fail to reach the postseason, add this to the list of reasons why.
He entered Saturday batting .269 with 14 home runs and 39 RBI. His on base-plus-slugging percentage of .781 is below his career average of .832 and would be the third-lowest of his eight-year career. After having a 7.2 WAR in 2021 according to Baseball Reference, he was at 3.2 this season. When the Twins faltered to a 10-12 record in July, Correa was one of the culprits, batting .175 with a .614 OPS.
This is unacceptable for someone who was fifth in MVP voting a year ago when he hit 26 home runs and collected 92 RBI. That was the player the Twins believed they were getting when they landed him. His defense has been great. His clubhouse presence, from all accounts, has been exemplary.
But there must be an impostor batting for him.
The Twins hoped for all around excellence from Correa, but that is not happening. Fangraphs has his value at $17.5 million so far this season. I'm aware that players aren't paid what they are worth, they are paid what they can get. But I believe the Twins were hoping for more offense from a premium player they are paying a premium price for.