Fatal hit-and-run charge filed against local DFL leader in northern Minnesota

Cynthia Arlene Martin said she thought she hit an owl or a turkey, according to the criminal complaint.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
November 21, 2024 at 3:03AM
Cynthia Arlene Martin, 65, was charged Tuesday in Itasca County District Court with criminal vehicular homicide in connection with the July 3 crash that killed 19-year-old Carter John Haithcock of Goodland, Minn. (Itasca County)

A leader in the DFL Party in northern Minnesota is charged with last summer running over and killing a pedestrian on Hwy. 169 and driving off. The next morning, she called 911 to report that she hit an owl or a turkey, according to a criminal complaint.

Cynthia Arlene Martin, 65, of Grand Rapids, was charged Tuesday in Itasca County District Court with criminal vehicular homicide in connection with the July 3 crash that killed 19-year-old Carter John Haithcock of Goodland, Minn.

Martin was charged by summons and is due in court Dec. 26. Court records do not list an attorney for her. A message was left with Martin seeking her response to the allegations.

Martin is chair of the DFL in the Eighth Congressional District, according to public records and a DFL official who spoke on the condition of anonymity.

According to the complaint:

A motorist told law enforcement that at about 11:18 p.m. he swerved to avoid a body on Hwy. 169 near Nashwauk. While he was pulled over and calling 911, another driver drove over the body, then stopped.

Investigators determined that Haithcock left a street dance in Nashwauk and was talking on his phone a few minutes before he was hit.

Officers arrived and determined from vehicle debris at the scene that it was a GMC from 1999-2006 that hit Haithcock.

Surveillance footage from a nearby gas station showed the driver of an SUV with a single headlight pulling over near the crash scene at 11:17 p.m., remaining there for less than 30 seconds and then driving off.

Shortly before 6 a.m. July 4, Martin called 911 and reported being involved in a crash. In a follow-up statement to law enforcement, she “stated she believed she struck an owl or a turkey. [She] stated that she did not stop and continued home.”

A State Patrol examination of Martin’s vehicle revealed a nonfunctional passenger-side headlight, damage to the right front of the SUV and cracks in the windshield. A piece of fabric recovered from the hood “was consistent with the sweatshirt worn by [Haithcock],” the complaint read.

Staff writer Kim Hyatt contributed to this report.

about the writer

about the writer

Paul Walsh

Reporter

Paul Walsh is a general assignment reporter at the Star Tribune. He wants your news tips, especially in and near Minnesota.

See More

More from Duluth

card image

Carlton County, just southwest of Duluth, hadn’t voted for a Republican presidential candidate since Herbert Hoover in 1928. Trump snapped that nearly centurylong streak earlier this month.