Opinion editor's note: Star Tribune Opinion publishes a mix of national and local commentaries online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.
•••
Our nation's campuses have seen a groundswell of support for Palestinians in the wake of Israel's indiscriminate retaliation for Hamas's attack on Oct. 7. Unfortunately, media reporting often gives the impression that such support is hate speech or support for terrorism.
One example is the Dec. 12 Star Tribune article, "Wartime words at U prompt letter," which describes Prof. Richard Painter's and former Regent Michael Hsu's request to the U.S. Department of Education that it conduct a federal investigation into antisemitic prejudice at the University of Minnesota Twin Cities campus.
The allegations reported in this article are unsubstantiated opinions of dubious veracity. By giving a public platform to these individuals without checking their claims or consulting with university community members against whom the allegations are leveled, the Star Tribune is helping to create a public perception that there is a culture of antisemitism and pro-terrorist sentiment on campus and that the university condones it.
As educators at the University of Minnesota, we object to the dangerous mischaracterization of our campus and our students fostered by this coverage of Painter and Hsu's complaint. Further, as the executive committee of the University of Minnesota-Twin Cities chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) — an organization with a long history of defending the free exchange of ideas on university campuses — we are compelled to respond to the allegations pertaining to academic freedom in the report.
Students and faculty on our campus have rallied several times in support of Palestinians in Gaza, where over 18,000 people have been killed in Israeli military attacks. However, none of these rallies have been "pro-Hamas," as Painter and Hsu claim. By labeling legitimate expressions of grief and solidarity as pro-terrorist rallies, Painter and Hsu malign U students and other U community members who are trying to draw attention to the injustice being done to Palestinians.
While the U administration was quick to acknowledge the impact on Israel and our community of Hamas's attack, it has yet to issue a public statement reassuring our Palestinian students of its support after Israel's bombardment of Gaza began. In this context, the Star Tribune's reporting of Painter and Hsu's claims trumpets them in a manner that adds to these students' trauma.