Dayton acts to step up response to child protection

December 26, 2014 at 8:27PM

Gov. Mark Dayton took immediate steps Monday that he said will protect Minnesota's children from abuse and prevent the kinds of systemic failures that led up to the death last year of 4-year-old Eric Dean.

The state will begin conducting random checks to see if counties are wrongly rejecting abuse reports, Dayton said, and will set up a team of child protection specialists to respond rapidly to social workers struggling with difficult cases. The governor also created a task force that will review how Minnesota's child welfare system can improve and make recommendations by the end of the year.

Dayton said he wants the Legislature to take action on those recommendations by January.

The changes follow a series of Star Tribune stories in recent months about child protection failures in the state, including the case of Eric, whose abuse was reported to Pope County child protection 15 times before he died.

"The picture of 4-year-old Eric Dean, smiling at the camera, despite a visible wound on his face, will haunt me for a long time," the governor said.

Some who have criticized the child protection system say Dayton's actions are the first positive steps they have seen in years. Dr. Lisa Hollensteiner, an Edina emergency room physician for 26 years, said she has become frustrated that abuse that she's required to report often fails to prompt action.

Dayton read a letter Hollensteiner wrote to the Star Tribune in which she said her "heart sinks" when she makes those reports, even though, as a trained medical professional, she should be taken seriously.

The task force will be formed by early October and co-chaired by Human Services Commissioner Lucinda Jesson and Ramsey County Commissioner Toni Carter.

In April, Carter, who is president of the Association of Minnesota Counties, authored a counterpoint in the Star Tribune challenging a previous newspaper story that Minnesota had one of the lowest rates of responding to abuse reports.

In her op-ed, Carter defended Minnesota's child protection system, which is county-run.

On Monday, Carter said she will have no biases on the panel other than "to make sure all children are safe."

"Even one failure to protect a child is too much," she said.

Carter said she also will consider naming critics of the child protection system to the task force and making those meetings open to the public. The governor's executive order requires those meetings to be open and to accept public comment.

Rich Gehrman, head of the advocacy group Safe Passages for Children, said the success of the task force will hinge on its membership.

"They need folks on the ground, who can say what's really going on," he said.

Dayton's opponents in the governor's race criticized his actions on child protection on Monday, with Independence Party candidate Hannah Nicollet saying they were "too little, too late."

Republican candidate Jeff Johnson said he was "troubled by [Dayton's] continuous pattern of creating or contributing to problems and then trying to claim credit for fixing them after the damage is done."

Johnson referred to a law passed by the Legislature this year that barred counties from considering prior abuse reports when deciding how to handle a new one.

That law was pushed by DHS to codify existing practice.

Dayton said Monday that law should be changed.

Jesson said that while Minnesota ranks high in overall child well-being, "we have seen far too many children fall through the cracks."

Brandon Stahl • 612-673-4626


Gov. Mark Dayton listened as Commissioner Lucinda Jesson answered questions Monday morning.
Gov. Mark Dayton listened as Commissioner Lucinda Jesson answered questions Monday morning. (Terry Sauer — Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
A photograph of Eric Dean with his arm broken was an exhibit presented as evidence by the prosecution during the May 2014 trial of Amanda Peltier in the death of her stepson, Eric Dean. ] JEFF WHEELER • jeff.wheeler@startribune.com Evidence in the murder trial of Amanda Peltier photographed in the Pope County Courthouse in Glenwood on Tuesday, July 15, 2014. The description for the exhibit reads, "Photograph. Pope County Human Services investigation on 7/20/11. Eric Dean fractured right h
the boy they couldn’t save: Read our special report about the case of 4-year-old Eric Dean (above), a victim of child protection failures. Go to startribune.com. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Human Services Commissioner Lucinda Jesson said Tuesday that the "[Department of Human Services] will expedite instructions to county and tribal child protection workers on how to implement the changes and begin considering all past reports of child abuse."
Commissioner Lucinda Jesson, left, along with Ramsey County Commissioner Toni Carter, will lead a task force on child welfare, created by Gov. Mark Dayton in response to the haunting news reports of the abuse and death of 4-year-old Eric Dean. (Star Tribune file photo/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Ramsey County Commissioner Toni Carter. Responding to the death of Eric Dean, Gov. Mark Dayton ordered two actions designed to step up the state's response to suspected child abuse. He ordered random state audits of counties' decisions on whether to accept or reject reports for investigation, and created a "rapid response" team of state child protection officials who will be available for consultation by counties. He also commissioned a task force on child welfare to offer recommendations for th
Ramsey County Commissioner Toni Carter, above, will help lead a new Minnesota task force on child welfare, to be co-chaired by Human Services Commissioner Lucinda Jesson, as part of Gov. Mark Dayton’s orders to step up the state’s response to suspected cases of child abuse or neglect. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Brandon Stahl

See More

More from Local

card image

Republicans across the country benefited from favorable tailwinds as President-elect Donald Trump resoundingly defeated Democrat Kamala Harris. But that wasn’t the whole story in Minnesota.

card image