Demolition of former Como Park church on hold, but there's a catch

July 16, 2019 at 1:52AM
Twin Cities German Immersion School students played in the former Catholic church turned gymnasium Tuesday. ] AARON LAVINSKY • aaron.lavinsky@startribune.com Neighborhood angst is brewing in Como Park, as the Twin Cities German Immersion School considers tearing down a former Catholic church it owns and has used as a gym and cafeteria to make room for expansion. Neighbors are not happy and want the school to find a way to preserve the former St. Andrew's Catholic Church, built in 1927. We
Preservationists want to save the former St. Andrew’s Catholic Church in Como Park, built in 1927. The Twin Cities German Immersion School says it has outgrown the building. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Neighbors fighting to save a former Como Park church from the wrecking ball have been granted a reprieve.

But there's a catch.

A Ramsey County judge has issued a temporary restraining order preventing the demolition.

However, Judge Jennifer Frisch is requiring preservationists to provide a $1.9 million bond to the Twin Cities German Immersion School by July 22, or the restraining order is off.

In June, a group of neighbors and preservationists called Save Historic St. Andrew's-Friends of Warrendale filed the lawsuit in Ramsey County District Court, seeking to save the church under the Minnesota Environmental Rights Act.

School officials want to raze the 92-year-old former church, which has been repurposed as a gymnasium, cafeteria and performance space, and replace it with a $5.1 million addition they say will better meet the needs of their 580 students.

Julie Alkatout, chairwoman of the school's board of directors, said the ruling attempts to strike a balance in the long, costly and emotional fight. "We are disappointed that we were unable to persuade the court on this initial record that a preservation order would impermissibly undermine educating schoolchildren in a proper setting," she said in a statement.

"We appreciate that the court recognized the substantial harm the school will suffer if the project is delayed, and we will await July 22 to see if the Friends of Warrendale will post a bond in the amount necessary to repay increased costs to the school," Alkatout said.

If bond is posted, the school is prepared to appeal the decision.

James Walsh • 612-673-7428

about the writer

about the writer

James Walsh

Reporter

James Walsh is a reporter covering St. Paul and its neighborhoods. He has had myriad assignments in more than 30 years at the Star Tribune, including federal courts and St. Paul schools.

See More