Five Extra Points: Boos banished, Bulldogs and a big night that didn't happen

The Vikings loss to the Eagles featured things to second guess, a missed opportunity for a special teams player and Eagles fans not getting to engage in one of their favorite pastimes.

September 15, 2023 at 5:20AM
Brandon Powell fumbled a punt return in the first quarter that the Eagles recovered. (Carlos Gonzalez, Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

1. Boos turn to cheers for Eagles OC

Brian Johnson's Welcome-to-Philly-as-New-Offensive-Coordinator moment took 14 minutes to arrive in Thursday night's game against the Vikings. Angry boos rained down from Lincoln Financial Field when the 36-year-old Johnson tried a way-too-fancy play that resulted in Jalen Hurts losing three yards on third-and-5. A missed 55-yard field goal led to a 55-yard Vikings touchdown drive and a 7-3 Eagles deficit. At that point, Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores was schooling the first-time NFL offensive coordinator. That ended on Philly's next possession. Johnson found the key to beating B-Flo's exotic looks: Punch 'em in the mouth. Johnson ran the ball 13 times on a 16-play, 75-yard drive to take a lead the Eagles never lost in a 34-28 victory. In the second half, the Eagles had a 15-play drive that went 44 yards and ended with a punt. But it kept Kirk Cousins and Justin Jefferson on the sideline for nine minutes.

2. Which Dawg would you take now? Cine or Davis?

Vikings General Manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah was on the clock with the 12th pick of the 2022 draft. He traded 20 spots down because he sensed tremendous value in Georgia safety Lewis Cine. The Eagles' Howie Roseman quickly traded up a spot into the 13th pick and grabbed Cine's 340-some pound college teammate, Jordan Davis. Thursday night, as Cine stood and watched his defensive teammates again, Davis was a beast per usual for the Vikings' makeshift offensive line. Davis' presence was felt early. A great swim move past left guard Ezra Cleveland to hurry and knock down Cousins on a third-and-9 incompletion. He also completely overpowered backup center Austin Schlottmann on a sack. If that wasn't enough Dawg DT power for Schlottmann, rookie Jalen Carter, the ninth overall pick, beat him on a tackle for loss on Alexander Mattison, who had 9 yards on four first-half carries.

3. Powell could have had a big night

Thursday night should have been a big night for Vikings punt returner Brandon Powell. The Eagles' special teams aren't great at covering punts or kicks. The Patriots had a 31-yard kick return and a 21-yard punt return against them in Week 1. Powell's chance arrived early. The Eagles had a 40-yard punt on their second possession. Powell made the first guy miss, followed his blocks and advanced the ball 20 yards. Not bad for a guy who shows some wiggle but averaged only 4.5 yards on four returns in Week 1. Unfortunately for Powell, he was stripped of and lost the ball. The Eagles didn't score, but the Vikings could have had the ball first-and-10 at the Philly 27. In their first seven quarters this season, they had seven turnovers and lost the turnover differential 7-1. There were 10 kickoffs in the game, all touchbacks.

4. Hurts bottled up … but not entirely

The Eagles' offense looked like a work in progress throughout Week 1 and into the early going Thursday night. Hurts looked unsure of himself and the offense until Johnson started pounding the ball 48 times for 259 yards (5.4) and three touchdowns. Initially, the Vikings did a nice job setting the edges to keep Hurts hemmed in. Danielle Hunter, who had three sacks, almost had another one early but his inside-out rush allowed Hurts to skirt past him for seven yards on third-and-5. Later, cornerback Byron Murphy lost the edge on an 8-yard run. Hurts also caught the Vikings napping up the middle on an 8-yard run that turned third-and-6 into Josh Elliott's 61-yard field goal closed the first half. And, of course, the legalization of the "push" play helped Hurts sneak for one first down and score twice from the 1-yard line.

5. Time (again) to ditch the touchback turnover rule

The Vikings don't give up. We'll give them that. But they have to be the sloppiest team in the league right now. And that sounds weird to say for a team that had only two penalties for 15 yards Thursday night. (Although, c'mon, Harrison Phillips. You're better than that offsides penalty. The Eagles were letting time run out in the third quarter when they somehow got you to jump offsides on third-and-3. What?!) Even Justin Jefferson was sloppy, losing the ball at the pylon for a touchback turnover late in the first half. This also is just a bad rule. After booth review, the field ruling went from Vikings ball at the 1-inch line to Eagles ball – all because replay showed the ball crossed over the top of the pylon by millimeters. People have been arguing for the NFL to change this rule for years. And they're right. It's too penal for the offense and too often rewards the defense too much for not doing anything.

The Star Tribune did not send the writer of this article to the game. This was written using a broadcast, interviews and other material.

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See More