The unexpected thing was, he died young, Gordon MacQuarrie, at only 56.
He was known for having the occasional cocktail, and he didn't push away from the dinner table too quickly. Still, 56 was a young age to go, even in the middle of the last century.
Yet that's not the most unusual part of MacQuarrie's life, or his death.
What's extraordinary is that today, 67 years after a heart attack killed him in the faceless brick apartment building on the edge of downtown Milwaukee that he shared with his wife, Ellen, there remains a cult of sorts in northwest Wisconsin dedicated to MacQuarrie's memory, and to his writing.
Dave Evenson of Cumberland, Wis., about 90 miles northeast of the Twin Cities, is one of the faction's kingpins, qualifying for that designation in part because he just published a third book of MacQuarrie's stories, the first two of which Evenson typed himself.
"I typed them with my own two fingers and I'm sure there are some typos in the books that weren't in the stories originally,'' Evenson said. "This third book, I got some help with the typing.''
MacQuarrie grew up in Superior, Wis., a workingman's town that made pulp cutters and farmers out of many of its high school graduates. Wanting instead to be a writer, MacQuarrie studied journalism at the University of Wisconsin.
MacQuarrie's pull on members of the cult, which calls itself The Old Duck Hunters Association Circle (ODHA Circle), of which Evenson is a card-carrying member, is such that until Keith Crowley's engaging biography of MacQuarrie was published in 2003, Evenson had never heard of the famous scribe.