Review: Latest Elinor Lipman comic novel is here to brighten your mood

Fiction: “Every Tom, Dick and Harry” is about a woman conducting an estate sale. At a bordello.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
January 23, 2025 at 2:30PM
photo of author Elinor Lipman
Elinor Lipman (Michael Benabib/Harper)

Elinor Lipman is as reliable as Chex Mix or your favorite afghan.

Her comic novels, often noted as the contemporary equivalent of Jane Austen classics, always hit the spot with warm characters, sharp dialogue, amusing situations and endings where everything works out for the people you hope it will work out for. The latest, “Every Tom, Dick and Harry,” is no different.

It’s about clever Emma, who hasn’t figured out how best to use her talents. When her father and stepmother retire and move, she drifts into their lives as if they’re hand-me-down slippers, moving into their home (with a friend of her father’s as a tenant) and taking over their business. She’s been helping with the estate sale firm since she was a kid, so it’s a comfortable fit but it’s not her passion and she’s not sure what is. Possibly Luke, the new police chief of her small New England town, who is handsome, an old acquaintance and maybe/maybe-not single?

Cover of "Every Tom, Dick and Harry" is a drawing of a bunch of people standing outside a large house.
Every Tom, Dick and Harry (Harper)

All five characters mentioned in that last paragraph are funny and distinctive, and Lipman has concocted a situation that offers plenty of comic possibilities: Emma’s latest project is a former B&B, except at least one of those B’s is “bordello.” What appears to be an average suburban home turns out to be a bawdy house inside, complete with a special staircase that leads to an area where the most intimate encounters occurred. The place has some decent silver and artwork but also a bunch of stuff Emma has never had to sell and an owner who’s not easy to deal with.

There’s nothing unexpected in “Every Tom, Dick and Harry,” like your afghan or Chex Mix (unless someone puts goldfish crackers in it, in which case: How dare you?). It’s as cozy and genial as a book with a madam and a fair number of freelance prostitutes could possibly be. There are more than the usual number of complications (everyone in town is scheming for Emma and Luke to hook up without knowing they already have, plus Emma’s boarder is romancing Luke’s mom). But the writer of “The Inn at Lake Devine” and “Ms. Demeanor” knows exactly how to shuffle things so all the good people find love and all the bad people go to jail or at least have to move to Florida.

If you’re a fan of Lipman, you’re going to love it. And, if you’re new to her, you’re in luck: Her 14 other comic novels are all terrific.

Every Tom, Dick and Harry

By: Elinor Lipman.

Publisher: Harper, 320 pages, $27.99.

about the writer

about the writer

Chris Hewitt

Critic / Editor

Interim books editor Chris Hewitt previously worked at the Pioneer Press in St. Paul, where he wrote about movies and theater.

See More

More from Books

card image
photo of author Alex Hay