More Minnesota foundations are shifting their money to organizations outside the state, supporting causes nationwide from Florida to New York and causing some experts to worry that may mean less money for financially struggling local nonprofits.
Steve Paprocki, whose Minneapolis consulting firm, Access Philanthropy, works with nonprofits on fundraising, said more Minnesota executives and donors likely are shifting their philanthropy to Florida and other states where they retire or vacation.
"Smaller organizations ... are suffering from this move of money from Minnesota to Florida," Paprocki said. "They're losing funders. When you lose a funder, it usually means you've lost a funder forever."
Overall, Minnesota foundations still mostly support local nonprofits. But according to a new report by the Minnesota Council on Foundations, publicly supported community foundations sent 22% of their funds outside Minnesota in 2021, up from 13.6% in 2019, as donors directed their dollars all over the country — from Wisconsin and neighboring states to Naples, Fla.
"We always approach this conversation from a deficit mentality like it's either us or them, which is not good for philanthropy," said Jeremy Wells, senior vice president of philanthropic services at the St. Paul & Minnesota Foundation. "I think we need to act out of a spirit of abundance and say it's wonderful that people from Minnesota also want to support other places around the country they care about."
Out-of-state giving at the St. Paul & Minnesota Foundation hasn't changed significantly over the years, increasing slightly from 14% in 2021 to 18% in 2022. That's due to a few grants to a donor's alma mater and southern Florida organizations after Hurricane Ian in 2022, Wells said.
Donors may want to contribute to causes in places where they grew up or keep second homes and that's OK, Wells said. He gives money to his alma mater in North Dakota and lent support to Maui after the Hawaiian wildfires this year. But he said most of his charitable giving stays in state.
"It's not a fixed pie," Wells said. "How can we just figure out how to make the pie bigger?"