There was some question as to P.J. Fleck’s level of superiority over Tim Brewster, the previous crazed promoter hired to coach the Gophers, when Fleck inherited a 9-4 football team from 2016 and turned it into an outfit that went 5-7 and was a 2-7 also-ran in the Big Ten the next season.
The issue of Fleck vs. Brewster was settled strongly in Fleck’s favor in his third season when the Gophers went 11-2, defeated Auburn in the Outback Bowl and wound up rated No. 10 in the final Associated Press poll.
Coach Brew didn’t make it through his fourth season in 2010. Since then, he has done TV work, and has been an assistant at Mississippi State, Florida State, Texas A&M, North Carolina, Florida, Jackson State, Colorado and now landing with the Charlotte 49ers, as they try to battle back from a 2-6 finish in the American Athletic Conference in 2023.
Meantime, Fleck is starting Season 8 with the Gophers, and was proclaiming his love for Minnesota at last week’s Big Ten preview sessions, which went on for three days in Indianapolis because this is now an 18-team jumble of colleges.
What did come through to those of us following from a distance was this:
Philip John Fleck Jr. is much more long-lasting and successful than Brewster, yet he remains just as full of authentic football gibberish as was Coach Brew.
The Big Ten West was an all-time worst in 2023, which is saying something, and the Gophers went 2-4 in the division and 3-6 in the conference. What was supposed to be a rugged schedule wound up ranked 36th nationally, thanks to the woeful West.
The season’s one notable victory came in the 12-10 bore-fest at Iowa City, and in weird fashion, when a replay official looking to discover if an Iowa punt returner had stepped out of bounds empowered himself to opine that Iowa’s Cooper DeJean’s motions toward blockers constituted a fair catch.