Minnesota Republicans will meet for a virtual state convention this weekend to endorse candidates for the U.S. Senate and U.S. House and to approve a party platform. Over the past half century, we have been to more of these state conventions than we might care to count. We won't be participants this year, though — and not just because we weren't invited.
Minnesota Republicans face a dilemma of both policy and politics. The politics first:
While the GOP continues to do well in local races in rural Minnesota, its statewide appeal has vanished. This isn't a new phenomenon. In the past 24 years, Republicans have won only three of 15 races for governor or U.S. senator. That's quite a swing from the pre-Tea Party, pre-anti-government Republican Party of Minnesota.
Between 1978, when one of the authors of this commentary was elected to the Senate, and 1994, when Arne Carlson won his second term as governor, Republicans won two-thirds of the races for governor and U.S. Senate.
Today, the GOP increasingly is being written out of the state's future. It isn't competitive in the urban centers and first-ring suburbs, and it is barely holding on in second- and third-ring communities. The largest and fastest-growing blocs of voters in the state more and more see the GOP as noncompetitive.
At best, the party's role now is to control a portion of state government and be the brakes on the DFL Party. Today it's the state Senate, but will that still be true after the 2020 census documents the continuing population shift to the metro area?
And that brings us to the party's policy problem. At the end of World War II, Minnesota was in the lower tier of wealth among the nation's states. In less than three decades, Minnesota earned the reputation as "the state that works."
Yes, it was DFL Gov. Wendy Anderson who appeared on the 1973 cover of Time magazine promoting "The Good Life In Minnesota" — but Republican ideas and innovation built much of the foundation, leading the way on everything from environmental protection to creating the state's first human-rights department, from tax reform to government reform.