Michael Tonkin has been a Met, a Twin, a Met, a Yankee and now a Twin again this season. He has appeared in 45 games and thrown 65 innings, with a shot at eclipsing his career high of 80 innings set last year — as a Brave.
All of which raises an unusual question: Is he having a good season or bad?
“I’ve been DFA’d four times this year — and claimed four times. That tells me I’m doing something right,” said Tonkin, who was drafted by the Twins in 2008 and pitched for them from 2013 to 2017. “If you’re getting claimed, that means you’re still a big leaguer and teams believe you belong in the big leagues.”
His 3.74 ERA, which got as low as 2.23 midway through his four-month stint with the Yankees, suggests as much, too. Count Twins manager Rocco Baldelli as a fan.
“He’s had some good outings. There’s a reason that teams keep looking to him, that people are interested in him,” Baldelli said. “He can get outs. He’s been good against righties. He’s got some good stuff for that. He can give you a little length. He can do a lot of things. A versatile guy.”
If that’s the case, why did the Twins pitch him only once after claiming him two weeks into the season? Tonkin pitched two innings in Detroit and gave up two quick runs but then struck out five of the final six hitters he faced.
Then the schedule, and a rainout earlier in the week, got him cut.
“I threw 48 pitches and we had a doubleheader the next day, so I was unavailable,” the 34-year-old righthander said. “They had to bring in somebody who was.”