A Twin Cities landscaper was in a client's yard in Eden Prairie in 2002 when he noticed a striking plant.
"There was a beautiful Japanese maple, about 4 feet tall and 8 feet wide," recalled Craig Frick, owner of Superior Lawn & Landscape in St. Bonifacius.
It had the distinctive lacy foliage, in a vivid purplish-red color. "And a trunk the size of my leg. It had obviously been there a long time. I thought, 'That's not normal.' "
Not normal because most Japanese maples are hardy to Zone 5, which makes them a risky and often short-lived choice in the Twin Cities, which is classified as Zone 4 by the USDA.
Not that some people don't try to grow the small ornamental tree that induces much zone envy among Minnesota gardeners. Some have had success, usually short-term, trying to create micro climates where Japanese maples can survive for a few growing seasons. Others grow them in large containers that are taken indoors for the winter.
Frick himself had tried to grow Japanese maples in the past.
"I've had Emperor 1, the tree form," he said. "They'll survive a winter or two, but they don't last. If people ask for them, I tell them they're not hardy." He doesn't even carry them in his garden center, Superior Outdoor Expressions.
But here was a mature Japanese maple, thriving, in Zone 4 Eden Prairie. It was more shrublike than treelike, with a spreading habit.