The prevailing anecdote in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic and the unrest following George Floyd’s murder was that droves of people moved out of Minneapolis. But it wasn’t true.
According to new data compiled by the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, some people did move, but not at a rate exceeding what had been typical before the pandemic.
“It is one of those things where it’s like the data and the narrative are just not in sync with each other,” said Minneapolis City Council President Elliott Payne.
These new insights come from a representative sample survey of all people in the United States who have a Social Security number and a credit file, compiled by the New York Fed Consumer Credit Panel.
The data offer the most detailed look into migration in the Twin Cities, particularly during years when both U.S. Census and Metropolitan Council estimates indicated population growth slowed in both Minneapolis and St. Paul, or even the possibility that both cities had lost residents.
It was also during a time when the pandemic increased the number of people working from home, prompting interest in more spacious homes with an extra room to serve as an office. And five days of protests following the murder of George Floyd evolved into riots, causing an estimated $500 million in damage to buildings, especially in parts of Minneapolis.
The city saw some of its highest violent crime rates in the year that followed. As of May, there were more than 70 unsolved homicides from between 2020 and 2022, according to police records analyzed by the Star Tribune.
Minneapolis City Council Member Jeremiah Ellison said North Side neighborhoods have been saddled with negative narratives even before 2020, and that this look into movement patterns is a valuable resource that people can point to when they’re confronted with flawed perceptions of the city.