Coming soon to the Lexington in St. Paul: Pie & Mighty

Beloved piemaker Rachel Swan will bring her popular baked treats to the landmark restaurant.

October 19, 2022 at 10:00AM
Pie and joy make a comeback at The Lex. (Courtney Perry, Star Tribune file/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

When beloved south Minneapolis pie shop Pie & Mighty announced its closure this summer, fans were heartbroken. Now, there's a glimmer of hope for those who jockeyed for the chance to purchase one of the crusty beauties.

Rachel Swan, Pie & Mighty's chief pie operating officer, head baker and inventor of its delectable lard and butter crusts, is back at the ovens. But this time, she's working for a restaurant. Her pies will be on the menu at The Lexington, St. Paul's venerable dining institution on Grand Avenue beginning Nov. 7, when the restaurant resumes Monday night dinner service.

Swan said the restaurant reached out to her and got her thinking about a new way to share her pies, without the overwhelming pressure of trying to operate a small bakery.

"We are excited to work with Rachel to bring more variety to our dessert menu," Lexington chef Nick O'Leary said in a statement. "The pies are delicious, and our guests will absolutely love them."

The specifics of the menu are currently under development, but there will be both sweet and savory pies, and they will hit the menu before the holiday season. That means it won't be long before fans will be able to enjoy the Lexington's iconic comfort dishes — with pie — in holiday elegance while listening to the jazz soundtrack in the Williamsburg room.

Rachel Swan (Provided/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Joy Summers

Food and Drink Reporter

Joy Summers is a St. Paul-based food reporter who has been covering Twin Cities restaurants since 2010. She joined the Minnesota Star Tribune in 2021.

See More

More from Eat + Drink

A plate with slices of Hmong sausage, a stuffed chicken wing and crispy pork belly, a mound of white sticky rice and shreds of white and orange papaya salad in a lettuce leaf

Lefse-wrapped Swedish wontons, a soothing bowl of rice porridge and a gravy-laden commercial filled our week with comfort and warmth.