•••
Many people justifiably abhor the Buffalo, N.Y., shooting. It's important to acknowledge that, obviously, 10 Black people died there. But even knowing that, I can't help but feel that the dehumanization of Payton Gendron, the perpetrator, is not helpful in the effort to end gun violence.
This may be hard for some to accept. But I believe that any person, with the right trauma or disorder and the right exposure to hateful rhetoric, can become a radicalized terrorist. I genuinely don't see Gendron as evil; rather, I view him with extreme pity and sorrow. I would argue that Gendron himself is also a victim of white supremacy here. The true perpetrators are the ones spreading these conspiracy theories online and motivating people to commit more acts of terrorism.
Gendron was merely a weapon in a greater proxy war between the alt-right and Black America. He deserves mental health and deradicalization treatment. Of course, he is very unlikely to receive those services. I hope that eventually, that might be possible.
Jackson Khatri, Edina
•••
In the wake of the Buffalo murders, James Densley and Jillian Peterson write an interesting commentary about mass killers ("Ideology is not what drives most mass killers," Opinion Exchange, May 17). They suggest that in most of the mass killings the motive is "unknown." They don't mention that killers' motives are often not released by law enforcement and that these are typically classified as "nonideological." Although it seems clear that any killer's motives are likely to be complex, nevertheless, the data show that patterns exist. The Anti-Defamation League's Center on Extremism has compiled data on extremist killings in the U.S. It found that "of the 443 people killed at the hands of extremists over the last 10 years, 333 (or 75%) were killed by right-wing extremists." Densely and Peterson note that traditional deterrence methods (armed security and harsh criminal sentences) are ineffective, and they offer some useful preventive strategies. However, understanding the patterns behind extremist murders can help direct actions by government and institutions to begin to take actions that will address our violence pandemic.