•••
It is difficult for readers to have an opinion about the commentary from Jay Ambrose published in the Sept. 21 Star Tribune ("Don't judge banned books by their covers"). The book and circumstances in question are unidentified. [Opinion editor's note: The online version of the commentary provides a link to more information about the books in question.] The commentary makes accusations against anonymous, unnumbered books in school libraries. His case in point is from a politician whose motives may be more complex than acknowledged. The description of the book expresses one person's opinion.
A few things I would say in responding to Ambrose's concerns:
School librarians are human beings, professionals and, often, parents. In many school libraries they also have teacher training. They aim to include books that will appeal to the age groups of the children they serve and the curriculum for those students.
There is a selection policy for the library, and reviews are used to decide which books suit the library and community. Given finite budgets, the selection process is rigorous. School librarians even in a single school may not all agree on a given item, but typically librarians will have internal discussions about selections and whether they meet the collection guidelines.
There is a process in libraries for addressing an official challenge to a book. That process involves other school staff, school leadership and school boards (publicly elected).
Any parent should look at books their children bring home from any library, including from school, and make decisions about its suitability for their child.