Russia may have used "cluster bombs" on a train station in eastern Ukraine last week, killing many and wounding many more.
At Fort Sill during officer training school, I was instructed in the use and effect of cluster bombs. We called them ICMs, improved conventional munitions. Fired from artillery or dropped from planes, a cluster bomb opens 100 meters or so above soft targets. They are useless against buildings, tanks and hard fortifications. When the shell opens, dozens to hundreds of bomblets are dispersed over as wide a range as chosen. Each bomblet flutters to the ground or hangs up in the trees.
They do not always explode on contact. In fact, one of their uses is to create an instant mine field. They are not always efficient at killing. But that's one of their design features. They are designed to maim. Killing is a bonus. Wounded people have to be taken care of, removing more potential combatants from the battlefield. The effect of ICMs was demonstrated to us in a film of the bomblets dropping on a herd of goats. They were a bloody, bleating mess. We used these weapons in the Vietnam War. The leftover bomblets took off the limbs of farmers and their kids for many years after, as they dropped from the trees.
I fear what it looked like at that Ukrainian train station.
John Widen, Minneapolis
•••
A recent commentary writer tried to make the case for more U.S. military involvement in Ukraine and concluded his piece with this line: "We did it in the Middle East. Let's do it in Europe. Stop the killing!" ("World's obligation: Engage, stop the killing in Ukraine," Opinion Exchange, April 9.)
"Stop the killing" — really? The U.S., along with some of its allies, lost an ill-conceived war in Vietnam that cost over 58,000 American lives. Thousands of service members and military contractors were also killed in Iraq after the U.S. mistakenly invaded this country to look for weapons of mass destruction that were never found. The trillions of dollars and 21 years the U.S. spent trying to plant the seeds of democracy in Afghanistan resulted in the deaths of another 2,500 American service members before our government decided to call it quits. Estimates of military and civilian casualties among the Vietnamese, Iraqis and Afghans vary widely between hundreds of thousands and millions.