Reproductive freedom: A choice precisely because it’s so personal

No one else, not even those close, can fully know what a woman goes through. Here’s my story.

By Mary Lou Rice

September 10, 2024 at 10:30PM
"The choices women make must be theirs, with all options available," Mary Lou Rice writes. (Richard Sennott/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Opinion editor’s note: Strib Voices publishes a mix of guest commentaries online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.

•••

A disagreement about reproductive freedom with my sister-in-law, whom I love, caught me by surprise. I suddenly realized just how personal this issue is for me.

I’m a 74-year-old woman with adult kids and five grandchildren, and it’s taken me 50-plus years to realize that this issue which has always been important to me is also so very personal.

I grew up as one of seven kids in a very Catholic family. My mom had 11 pregnancies. Within that 11 were two miscarriages and two babies who died at birth. There’s a nine-year gap between my older brother and me. That’s when those tragic losses occurred. As you might imagine, I was prayed-for, wanted, welcomed and so very loved.

No one in my family had ever been to college, so it was hugely special that I chose to go, and scholarships, loans and work allowed that to happen. I succeeded and was selected as a resident assistant in the dorm for my sophomore year. Life was exciting.

But then at the beginning of second semester, just after I turned 20, I became pregnant. It was a terrible situation for me. I felt like I was just beginning to explore what my life could be; what I might do in the world. The distress I felt was enormous. It’s hard for me now to recall what it was like, but that disagreement with my sister-in-law brought it crashing down once again.

Through my distress, I was able to look at options. I lived in a state where abortions could be obtained within a two-hour drive. I knew this because one of the girls on my wing had one. So, I considered that option and agonized some more. The irony was that I was the RA, counseling girls who were my neighbors. And here I was almost failing classes because of this stressful secret.

The young man I was seeing was responsible, sensible and a few years older than me. He was ready to marry and was willing to support whatever decision I thought was best for me. I did love him, but I really didn’t want to be married yet. It was an agonizing time.

The end of this story is that we did marry. I gave birth to a beautiful baby girl who was cherished and welcomed by family and college friends. My new husband knew how committed I was to finishing school and how disappointed I was at thinking I might not do that.

I went back to college after missing only one semester.

My husband was a veteran and had GI Bill benefits. We both worked part time jobs. A grandmotherly neighbor watched our daughter for free. With help from neighbors, family and friends, we made it work.

Three years later in the middle of my first year as a teacher, we chose to get pregnant. This time a baby boy was born and welcomed with joy. For the record, we’re still married, and we’ve made that work, too.

Today, however, when I think of our four beautiful granddaughters and the fact that they don’t have the same personal reproductive freedom I had, I’m filled with anguish, rage, sometimes despair, and a willingness to work to change that situation.

I was a young woman who went through hell as I considered my options. But I had the freedom to get through that hell, knowing there were options.

My rage comes from having politicians think they know what’s right for a woman who becomes pregnant. In most cases, no one else has a clue what a woman goes through — not even a man who loves her. It’s gut-wrenching and heart-rending and all-consuming. No one has the right to impose their beliefs on a woman who is facing this life-altering, immensely difficult decision.

I made a choice that shaped my future, just as all choices do. But, I was the one who made the choice. It was personal.

The choices women make must be theirs, with all options available.

Mary Lou Rice, of St. Paul, is a retired leadership consultant.

about the writer

about the writer

Mary Lou Rice

More from Commentaries

card image

Despite all our divisions, we can make life more bearable for each other through small exchanges. Even something as small as free snacks on a flight.