At the most recent of dozens of meetings on the remaking of a Minneapolis institution, Nye's Polonaise Room, the city's preservationists and a developer were at an impasse over heating and air conditioning vents.
After a word with the developer, architect Aaron Roseth stepped to a microphone and firmly told the preservation commission that the change they wanted cost too much. Besides, Roseth said, "You've approved this type of system on other projects in the same historic district."
He would know. Roseth and his colleagues at Elness Swenson Graham Architects Inc., simply called ESG, dominate the Twin Cities market in the design of new housing and hotels, and they shepherded dozens of difficult projects in historic districts in recent years. With about 100 people, ESG isn't the largest architecture firm in the region, but it is arguably the most influential, responsible more than any other for the look of the cities and their suburbs over the past decade.
From low-income rental apartments in struggling neighborhoods to multimillion-dollar lakeside condominiums, ESG is known for getting projects designed, approved and built as quickly as possible. It won accolades for championing "city-building," a concept that discourages suburban sprawl by creating high-density, urban-style communities with gathering spaces, easy access to mass transit and amenities that are within walking distance.
Its buildings are typically a mix of contrasting materials and bold colors, leading to criticism that its designs look too much alike. Roseth, one of eight principals at ESG, said the tension between volume and distinctiveness of work never ends. "Our job is a constant convincing of communities and neighbors, and, sadly, sometimes the conversation about high design gets lost," he said.
The Twin Cities is brimming with decorated architecture firms, some of which focus on medical, office and industrial buildings. While the size of those types of buildings dwarfs residential and hospitality projects, new hotels and apartments outnumber the others and are often positioned in higher-traffic areas, elevating their visibility.
ESG has a reputation for knowing what the market wants and designing project concepts quickly — sometimes in just a weekend — using what the company calls a "starter kit" that serves as a template to determine the feasibility of a building. That includes floor plans, renderings, unit layouts.
"We operate more like an ad agency than a design firm because of our speed," Roseth said.