Seven critical mistakes in the early days of the Jacob Wetterling investigation

Stearns County sheriff said there were critical missteps in the first weeks and months of the 1989 kidnapping of Jacob Wetterling

September 21, 2018 at 2:02AM

1. Investigators should have more thoroughly pursued reports of assaults of young boys in the Paynesville, Minn., area between August 1986 and late fall 1988 that showed strong similarities to the kidnapping of Jacob Wetterling. Paynesville is about 30 miles from St. Joseph, Minn., where Jacob was abducted in October 1989 while headed home from a convenience store with his brother and best friend.

2. A drawing of the suspect in the Cold Spring abduction bears strong resemblance to a photograph of Heinrich used in a 1990 photo lineup after Jacob's abduction. Investigators should have given it more weight.

3. A fiber found on the Cold Spring victim's snowmobile suit was consistent with fibers from Heinrich's Mercury Topaz. Again, it was an important but underplayed clue.

4. After the FBI took over the investigation within days of Jacob's abduction, investigators followed thousands of erroneous and farfetched leads across the country rather than sufficiently focusing on compelling local evidence.

5. Other victims from the Paynesville and St. Joseph assaults should have been present during a January 1990 lineup that included Heinrich. Investigators also failed to conduct a voice lineup. Victims said their attacker had a low, raspy voice.

6. Investigators erred in February 1990 when they arrested a drunk Heinrich late at night at a bar and interviewed him.

7. Despite the fact that Heinrich was an early suspect, there is no mention of him in the case files for more than 20 years.


Evidence photos of Danny Heinrich were part of Sheriff Don Gudmundson's presentation.
Evidence photos of Danny Heinrich were part of Sheriff Don Gudmundson's presentation. The closed investigative file in the Jacob Wetterling abduction was released to the public Thursday morning at 10:06 a.m. by the Stearns County Sheriff's Office. Sheriff Don Gudmundson held a press conference to discuss the document release. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
COURTESY STEARNS COUNTY. Composite sketch of the Wetterling abduction suspect, next to Danny Heinrich's lineup shot from 1990.
A sketch of the suspect in the Cold Spring abduction bears a strong resemblance to a photograph of Danny Heinrich that was used in a photo lineup after the Jacob Wetterling abduction. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
COURTESY STEARNS COUNTY. Tires on Danny Heinrich's car matched tire tracks found at the Wetterling abduction scene.
Tires on Heinrich’s vehicle matched tire tracks found at the Wetterling abduction scene in 1989. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
COURTESY STEARNS COUNTY. Composite sketch of the Wetterling abduction suspect, next to Danny Heinrich's lineup shot from 1990. ORG XMIT: MIN1809201512371000
COURTESY STEARNS COUNTY. Composite sketch of the Wetterling abduction suspect, next to Danny Heinrich's lineup shot from 1990. ORG XMIT: MIN1809201512371000 (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
COURTESY STEARNS COUNTY. Danny Heinrich's shoes.
Shoe prints at the abduction scene matched Heinrich’s shoes, but investigators didn’t focus on the link. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

James Walsh

Reporter

James Walsh is a reporter covering St. Paul and its neighborhoods. He has had myriad assignments in more than 30 years at the Star Tribune, including federal courts and St. Paul schools.

See More

More from Local

card image