St. Paul suspect in family slaying kills himself in jail

Patrick McHugh was accused of killing three members of his family.

August 21, 2010 at 4:52AM
This undated photo provided by the Ramsey County Sheriff's office shows Patrick Thomas McHugh. McHugh, was arrested Friday night July 16, 2010 as he tried to leave the scene of a shooting and is being held at the Ramsey County Law Enforcement Center. Police on Sunday identified the shooting victims as McHugh's sister Mary Malicki and her husband Clyde Malicki, both 58, and their daughter Kristy Malicki, 33, all of Cottage Grove.
Patrick Thomas McHugh was arrested July 16, 2010 as he tried to leave the scene of a shooting. (Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

A St. Paul man accused of killing three family members last month in a Highland Park home he shared with his mother committed suicide Friday in the Ramsey County jail, authorities said.

Patrick McHugh, 55, who had expressed suicidal thoughts when he was arrested, was found unresponsive in his jail cell about 5 p.m. Friday, and could not be revived, according to the Sheriff's Office.

McHugh had been taken off suicide watch at the jail on July 27 on the advice of a Health Department psychologist, the Sheriff's Office said.

A news release said that McHugh was alone in the cell at the time of his death, but did not state how he killed himself. Holli Drinkwine, a Sheriff's Office spokeswoman, said Friday night that early indications were that he died of apparent asphyxia through self-strangulation. St. Paul police and the county medical examiner's office are investigating.

On July 16, McHugh allegedly shot and killed his sister Mary McHugh Malicki, 58; her husband, Clyde Malicki, 58, and their daughter, Kristy Malicki, 33, in the home at 1825 Munster Av. A second sister, Kathleen McHugh Dorgan, was shot in the cheek and neck, but survived.

On the night he was arrested, McHugh was quoted saying, "I've really done it now," according to second-degree murder charges filed against him in Ramsey County District Court. "I should have got a motel -- should have killed myself."

The shootings occurred after McHugh reportedly had been out drinking. His sisters had been at the house to care for their mother, who had recently suffered a stroke. That night, the charges state, McHugh came home with a "wild look." Before he started shooting, he declared he had power of attorney and said, "I'm sorry I have to do this," the charges said. Kathleen McHugh, 80, the siblings' mother, was not harmed.

At police headquarters, he also allegedly bemoaned having left the gun in the house, saying, "I should have held onto that gun and I'd be done."

On Friday, Drinkwine declined to discuss why McHugh was put on a suicide watch or why he was taken off. She also declined to describe the precautions generally taken when an inmate is on a suicide watch.

According to the Sheriff's Office, routine half-hour checks had been made on McHugh and the jail's other 391 inmates.

McHugh's family was notified of his death Friday evening, Drinkwine said.

alonetree@startribune.com • 612-673-4109 slemagie@startribune.com • 952-882-9016

about the writer

about the writer

Anthony Lonetree

Reporter

Anthony Lonetree has been covering St. Paul Public Schools and general K-12 issues for the Star Tribune since 2012-13. He began work in the paper's St. Paul bureau in 1987 and was the City Hall reporter for five years before moving to various education, public safety and suburban beats.

See Moreicon