Victoria City Council members who violated the state Open Meeting Law dozens of times can't be removed from office, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled Wednesday.
That's because the infractions occurred as part of a single trial, the high court said, and not as three separate, sequential violations as required under the law to unseat public officials.
The ruling upholds a previous decision by the Minnesota Court of Appeals, as well as the original district court ruling.
"Three courts have concluded with finality that these council members should not be removed," said Janel Dressen, the defendants' attorney.
Larry Gubbe, one of the plaintiffs, said he was disappointed by the ruling but that it wasn't completely unexpected. "We hoped that the number and the egregious nature of the violations would sway the judges," he said.
"I think the defendants won on a technicality," Mayor Tom Funk said.
The suit was filed in 2014 by a group of Victoria residents that included Funk. They alleged that then-Mayor Thomas O'Connor and council members Lani Basa, James Crowley and Thomas Strigel had deliberately and repeatedly violated the Open Meeting Law by holding secret meetings and exchanging e-mails to avoid scrutiny relating to the construction of City Hall and other buildings.
Two subsequent lawsuits were filed by other plaintiffs, including Gubbe, each containing different allegations related to breaking the state's sunshine laws.