Every cook I know makes a "definitive" chili. But the truth is that no such recipe exists.
Some swear by meat only, others use a meat-and-bean mix, then there are vegetarian and vegan options. But whatever the recipe, there are three key elements — the pot, the spices and low, slow heat.
Chili must be simmered in a wide, very heavy-bottomed pot so that the ingredients don't burn during the long cooking time. The pot may be stainless, enameled cast-iron or a Dutch oven. Avoid using plain cast iron because the acidity from the tomatoes may react with the metal and create an off taste.
Great chilis are built around a protein: beef, pork, lamb, chicken, turkey, beans — alone or in combination. Plan on about 1/4 to 1/3 pound of meat per person, or about a cup of cooked beans per person, or a mix of the two.
All real chilis are seasoned with chiles: fresh chile peppers and/or dried chile peppers or dried ground chile peppers (aka chile powder). Some call for chili powder, which is a mix of dried, ground chiles and other spices such as Mexican oregano, cumin and garlic powder.
The first step in making any chili is to brown the primary ingredients to lay down a flavor base. If it's meat, start by caramelizing the pieces in a little oil. If it's a vegetarian or vegan dish, start by sautéing the onions and garlic. Next, deglaze the pan with beer or stock, then add the other ingredients so that everything will simmer away on its own, freeing the cook to move on to other tasks such as baking cornbread, reading a book or taking a nap.
The best chili? It's the one you like!
Lamb Chili
Serves 4 to 6.