The Chocolate Chip Cookie Project
NEW YORK TIMES' CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Reason to bake: Where to begin? This recipe is perhaps the ultimate in bake-at-home chocolate chip cookies, and so worth its various hassles. Yes, the dough requires a 24- to 36-hour chilling period (to fully hydrate the dry ingredients), but patience pays off, big time. No, that's not a typo in the ingredients list: Both cake flour and bread flour are essential. Plan on buying (some might say "investing in") a lot of bittersweet chocolate. And don't forget the sea salt.
Tip: By all means, splurge on the (not-inexpensive) Valrhona fèves — they're available at Kitchen Window (3001 Hennepin Av. S., Mpls., 612-824-4417, www.kitchenwindow.com) and at Amazon.com — but rest assured, far more affordable (and widely available) bittersweet chocolate bars and chips from Ghirardelli work just fine, and they're a fraction of the cost. One premium bar definitely worth trying is the Divine brand, available in the candy aisle at Whole Foods Market.
Going nuts
PECAN-CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Reason to bake: It's easy to fall head-over-heels for these sturdy, decidedly chewy cookies, and the pecans contribute a resonating flavor that complements the predominant chocolate-butter notes.
Tip: Corn syrup may sound off-putting in a cookie, but even this small amount (which, liquids-wise, pretty much replaces the missing egg white) contributes to the caramel-ey appeal of the final result.
A chef's solution
THOMAS KELLER'S CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Reasons to bake: Leave it to a top chef to improve upon the time-tested Toll House method. Keller's easy-peasy solution encourages impromptu baking, even eliminating the half-hour required for room-temperature butter. The lack of vanilla extract helps to accentuate (in a sneakily delicious way) the molasses lurking within dark brown sugar.
Tip: Shaking the loose particles from chopped chocolate is a handy — and quintessentially Thomas Keller-ey — suggestion, resulting in a tidy cookie.
Home sweet home
THE BEST CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Reasons to bake: The ultimate in nothing-fancy, lunch-box comfort. Oh, and their small size — and heart-healthy oats — makes for a guilt-free (well, not-so-guilty, anyway) indulgence.
Tip: Skip the butterscotch chips. No cookie is improved by their phony flavor and equally artificial color (even a premium brand, such as Guittard, isn't all that), so go with a tastier, more natural alternative, such as toasted pecans.
Follow the French
EDUOARD'S CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES
Reasons to bake: This French formula is a pale and pleasingly plump diversion from le Toll House tradition. Ground almonds add visual and textural appeal, as well as a mellow, nutty bite. And yes, the dough is crumbly — the high flour content is the culprit — but don't fret. It works, beautifully.
Tip: The mid-baking press-with-a-spatula step is odd, but useful. Just be sure to keep the spatula clean, or the chocolate might streak.
The 23rd installment of the beer fest will take place Oct. 12 at Boom Island Park in Minneapolis.