This isn't shrimp scampi — it's even better

Without overpowering garlic, the shrimp have a chance to shine.

By Melissa Clark

The New York Times
April 12, 2023 at 11:00AM
Butter-poached shrimp with dill mayonnaise in New York, March 8, 2023. Nix the garlic for coriander seeds and a dollop of dill-speckled mayo for a subtle, speedy dish that's all about the shrimp. Food styled by Barrett Washburne. (James Ransom/The New York Times)
Nix the garlic for coriander seeds and a dollop of dill-speckled mayo for a subtle, speedy dish that’s all about the shrimp. (Photo by James Ransom and food styling by Barrett Washburne, New York Times/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

This is not a recipe for shrimp scampi.

I know, everyone loves scampi. That garlicky, buttery, winy sauce, so easy to pour over plump, pink shrimp, whether eaten with pasta or mopped up with a piece of crusty bread. Then there's the heavenly aroma. Is there anything more seductive than garlic sizzling in a pan of butter and wine?

In fact, scampi sauce is so good on its own that you don't even need the shrimp. Pour it on chicken, swab it over summer squash, drizzle it on a pair of old galoshes, it will all taste great. That sauce is stealing the spotlight from anything you pair with it.

Turns out it's garlic's fault. Leave out the garlic and our formerly shrimp scampi becomes all about the shrimp. Compensate with a pinch of cracked coriander seeds to add a complex, earthy note, and what was once pungent and assertive becomes mild and delicate. The briny succulence of sweet shrimp can shine through at last.

So this recipe, very much like scampi, contains shrimp, butter, wine and lemon — but no garlic. ("Are you feeling OK?" my husband asked.)

I also skip the pasta to keep things simple, and serve the shrimp in bowls surrounded by some of their tangy poaching liquid, then top them off with a dollop of dill-speckled mayonnaise. The mayonnaise rounds out the wine and lemon, adding richness to the shrimp and body to the broth.

Without any of the garlic to chop, the whole thing comes together even more quickly than scampi, and it's lighter and sweeter, too.

As with any dish starring shrimp, try to seek out wild rather than farmed crustaceans if possible, or look for farms that have been certified by the Global Seafood Alliance, which ensures responsible and sustainable farming practices.

Once you've found great shrimp, it's essential not to overcook them. Watch them closely as they turn from translucently bluish (or brownish, or purplish, depending on the variety) to opaque and pink-striped. Their bodies should firm up in the poaching liquid, but remain long and vaguely ear-shaped, without curling up into tight rounds — a definite sign of overcooking.

You can serve this dish as an appetizer, as is, or as a main course rounded out with some bread to catch the nuanced, buttery sauce. Although shrimp is now center stage, this subtly delectable sauce deserves its own star turn.

Ingredients for butter-poached shrimp with dill mayonnaise in New York, March 8, 2023. Nix the garlic for coriander seeds and a dollop of dill-speckled mayo for a subtle, speedy dish that's all about the shrimp. Food styled by Barrett Washburne. (James Ransom/The New York Times)
All the ingredients for a subtle, speedy dish that’s all about the shrimp. (Photo by James Ransom and food styled by Barrett Washburne, New York Times/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Butter-Poached Shrimp with Dill Mayonnaise

Serves 3 to 4.

Poaching shrimp in a combination of butter, lemon juice and white wine gives them a bright, tangy flavor and plump, succulent texture, and it takes only about five minutes. Served in bowls with a little of their broth and a dollop of dill-speckled mayonnaise, they're rich and soupy, perfect with a hunk of crusty bread on the side to mop up every last drop. From Melissa Clark.

For the shrimp:

• 2 tsp. whole coriander seeds

• 4 tbsp. unsalted butter

• 1/2 c. dry white wine, plus more if needed

• 1 lb. shelled large shrimp

• Juice of 1/2 lemon

• Pinch of fine sea or table salt

For the dill mayonnaise:

• 1/4 tsp. finely grated lemon zest

• Juice of 1/2 lemon, plus more to taste

• 1/4 c. chopped fresh dill, plus more for garnish

• 1/2 c. mayonnaise

• 1/4 tsp. fine sea or table salt

Directions

Using a mortar and pestle or a cutting board and the flat side of a knife, crack the coriander seeds. Add to a large dry saucepan over medium heat and toast for 1 minute, or until fragrant.

Add butter and wine to the coriander in the pan, and swirl until butter has melted, about 2 to 3 minutes.

Add shrimp, lemon juice and pinch of salt. The liquid should come about halfway up the sides of the shrimp. If needed, add a splash more wine to the pan.

Gently poach shrimp for 2 minutes, then flip. Poach for another 1 to 2 minutes, or until they turn pink and are just cooked through.

While shrimp are poaching, make the dill mayonnaise: In a small bowl, whisk together lemon zest and juice, dill, mayonnaise and salt. Taste, and add more salt and lemon juice if needed.

Pour shrimp and all of their juices into a shallow bowl, and top with dollops of dill mayonnaise. Garnish with dill fronds and serve.

about the writer

Melissa Clark

More from Recipes

A bowl of soup on a cutting board. The bowl is filled with golden corn soup topped with poblanos, queso fresco, crispy tortilla strips with a squeeze of lime.

Don’t let sweet corn season pass without trying this recipe for Creamy Corn and Poblano Soup.

A glass is filled with fresh blueberries, raspberries and blackberries topped with a dollop of fresh ricotta.
A platter with chicken shawarma skewers, tomatoes and cucumbers served with a side of dipping sauce and pitas.