Type of helicopter that crashed in Minnesota known for its reliability

Mishap rate "relatively low" for the UH-60 Black Hawk, which has been used by the U.S. military since 1978.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
December 7, 2019 at 6:30AM
UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters at Kandahar Air Field, Afghanistan.
UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters at Kandahar Air Field, Afghanistan. (The Associated Press)

The type of helicopter that crashed in a central Minnesota farm field Thursday is the military’s long-running workhorse with a reputation of reliability.

While the National Guard helicopter crash is still under investigation, questions surfaced Thursday about the Sikorsky UH-60 Black Hawk involved in the incident.

The possible causes of the crash fall into three camps: a material, maintenance or circumstantial failure. Most incidents involving this type of helicopter fall into the third category, which could include weather or poor visibility that could cause a pilot to inadvertently run into power lines or trees, said Lee Benson, the former chief pilot for the Los Angeles County Fire Department, where he flew UH-60 Black Hawks.

However, the National Guard said this helicopter was out on a maintenance test flight, which could point to a maintenance issue, he said.

“I am not going to make an assumption on the cause of the crash,” Benson said, “but, certainly, investigators are going to be looking closely at the part they were testing.”

A material failure would be something inherently flawed with the helicopter’s engineering. Anything is possible, Benson said, but the UH-60 is a “stellar aircraft” with double and triple safety redundancies.

For now, the military is handling the investigation. The nation’s primary accident investigator, the National Transportation and Safety Board, has not been called in to help, a NTSB spokesman said Friday. The NTSB investigates civil aviation incidents, but only steps in on military incidents upon request or if the aircraft had a civilian registration.

The U.S. military does not publish aviation accident data, but through a Freedom of Information Act request, Defense News compiled a database of all military aviation mishaps from 2011 to 2017. Of the 98 UH-60 Black Hawk mishaps reported during that time period on L-model and M-model Black Hawks — including combat and noncombat situations — about 25 could be related to mechanical problems, but only three resulted in significant damage or loss of life.

“For the amount of flight hours Black Hawks log worldwide, its mishap rate is actually relatively low,” said Jen Judson, a Defense News reporter who monitors military aviation safety. “It’s a very reliable aircraft.”

UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters have been in use by the U.S. military since 1978. Today, the Black Hawk is primarily used as a transport vehicle, with the capacity to carry 11 soldiers. The UH-60 is used for a variety of purposes, including air assault, medical evacuations, command and control, stability and support operations.

about the writer

about the writer

Kristen Leigh Painter

Business Editor

Kristen Leigh Painter is Business Editor.

See Moreicon

More from Greater Minnesota

See More
card image
Lisa Meyers McClintick

Its dried leaves are ideal for teas and tinctures in the cold months. As the snow melts, its leaves are among the first to appear.

card image
BRIAN PETERSON • brianp@startribune.com INTERNATIONAL FALLS, MN - January 31-Feb. 2nd ] The Arrowhead 135 Ultra Marathon, from International Falls to Tower Minnesota, follows the scenic and rugged Arrowhead State Snowmobile Trail and attracts some of the best ultra-athletes in the world. Competitiers can Bike, run or ski the 135 mile race that challenges the body and the mind and presents participants with some of the coldest conditions in ultra marathon racing. (IN THIS PHOTO) Being alone and c