In a sign of the default pessimism of Vikings fans, most of the correspondence I received after writing Tuesday about the best-case scenarios for Minnesota in the NFL draft was an effort to douse any optimism with cold water.
A sample email: “Whether matching a quarterback to draft pick value or trading down to add talent elsewhere, there’s a complication to the Vikings draft. This front office can’t evaluate talent.”
Another: “Lets not get too excited. It seems History has taught us almost every time the Vikings have given away a boatload of picks it has BACKFIRED!”
Indeed, the long-range worst possible scenario is that the Vikings draft a QB who doesn’t turn out to be the right one. If that happens, they will almost certainly languish through a longer rebuild and need to draft another quarterback in a few years under a new regime.
But we won’t know that outcome for a long time. What we’re focused on now is the process.
That said, it’s possible draft night itself will go sideways for the Vikings. With that in mind, here is the other side of this weeks discussion: the three worst-case scenarios for the Vikings in the draft, as I talked about on Wednesday’s Daily Delivery podcast.
Tie-1: The Vikings get shut out of future trades up the draft board and aren’t able to take a quarterback they think can be a franchise player. Nobody has to trade with the Vikings. What if the top five teams stay put -- including the top three taking quarterbacks Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels and Drake Maye -- and then the Giants pick J.J. McCarthy at No. 6. Or the Giants package No. 6 and future picks to move up to No. 4.
Simply put, if the Vikings have a short list of potential franchise QBs, and they aren’t able to draft one, their rebuild will be delayed by a year without a guarantee they will be able to get their franchise QB in 2025.