When is an interview too tough? CBS News grappling with question after Dokoupil interview

NEW YORK — An internal debate over CBS News host Tony Dokoupil's pointed interview with author Ta-Nehisi Coates about Israel has spread to the boardroom, with the chief of the network's parent company saying Wednesday that it was a mistake to reprimand him.

Shari Redstone, o utgoing head of Paramount Global, expressed support for Dokoupil while speaking at the Advertising Week conference on Wednesday. CBS News leaders on Monday had reprimanded Dokoupil, a ''CBS Mornings'' host for an interview they said didn't meet their standards.

''I think we made a mistake,'' Redstone said, according to published reports.

Later Wednesday, CBS network President and CEO George Cheeks issued a supportive statement for Wendy McMahon, the boss of CBS News, who was involved in criticizing the interview.

''There has been strong and growing discord within CBS News that needed to be addressed in an editorial meeting,'' Cheeks said. ''This must lead to further substantive dialogue about perceptions of inconsistent treatment, implicit bias and the important standards our News division has in place to establish guardrails for fairness and objectivity.''

The seven-minute morning show interview on Sept. 30 was about Coates' new book of essays, and Dokoupil zeroed in right away on a section about Israel and Palestinians in the West Bank, saying the essay ''would not be out of place in the backpack of an extremist.'' He wondered why Coates' writing did not include references to Israel being surrounded by enemies that want to eliminate the country.

''Is it because you just don't believe that Israel in any condition has a right to exist?'' he asked.

''I wrote a 260-page book,'' Coates said. ''It is not a treatise on the entirety of the conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians.''

Dokoupil later asked Coates about what offended him about the existence of a Jewish state, and he said that Palestinians ''exist in your narrative merely as victims of Israel,'' as if they had not been offered peace in any juncture.

Coates said that he was offended when anyone — including the Palestinians who talked to him for his book — are treated as second-class citizens in the country where they live, comparing it to the Jim Crow-era United States where his ancestors grew up.

In the staff call on Monday, CBS News chief Wendy McMahon and her deputy, Adrienne Roark, said several journalists in the company had reached out to them about the interview.

''There are times we have not met our editorial standards,'' Roark said, citing Dokoupil's interviews and other comments made by CBS personnel that she did not identify.

She said that the problems had been addressed, but neither she nor CBS explained what this meant.

McMahon told staff members on the call that she expected its contents would remain confidential. But a tape of it was posted within hours on The Free Press news site.

Dokoupil did not immediately return messages seeking comment. A spokesman for Coates did not return a message.

Dokoupil is one of three ''CBS Mornings'' hosts, along with Gayle King and Nate Burleson. All three participated in the interview with Coates, but with the exception of an opening question by Burleson and a brief one at the end by King, it was dominated by Dokoupil.

Dokoupil is married to NBC News journalist Katy Tur. He has two children from a previous marriage who both live with their mother in Israel. In the wake of the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack, Dokoupil said on the show that, ''as a father, I think people can understand if somebody, anybody, is firing rockets in the direction of your children without regard to whether they are struck or not, you're going to feel a thing or two.''

Management received immediate pushback on the call from Jan Crawford, CBS News' chief legal correspondent, who said that it's a journalist's obligation to ask tough questions when somebody comes on the air to present a one-sided view.

''I don't see how we can say that failed to meet our editorial standards,'' Crawford said. She said she worried that it would make her think twice when conducting interviews.

___

David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at http://x.com/dbauder.

___