It must have been a big surprise to Jimmy Williams and his attorney, Richard Hunegs, when Hennepin County Judge Regina Chu ruled that Williams had no claims in his suit against the University of Minnesota over quitting his job as an assistant coach at Oklahoma State so he could take a job as an assistant under new coach Tubby Smith.
Williams claimed that the reason he didn't get the Gophers job was that Athletic Director Joel Maturi overruled Smith because Williams had been involved in some NCAA recruiting violations when he had worked for coach Jim Dutcher.
Hunegs was convinced that, under any circumstances, they would win a good settlement for Williams, who is now out of a job.
Maturi has made it clear that his policy is not to hire any coaches who have been in trouble with the NCAA, and for that reason, Williams wasn't going to be on the Gophers staff because of his previous NCAA violations with Minnesota.
According to University of Minnesota attorney Mark Rotenberg, "the judge said that essentially all of [Williams'] claims lacked legal merit, had not been filed in the proper court and that Maturi had a privilege ... to make the call he did."
Rotenberg said that the judge didn't go into detail regarding her decision, but only that Williams' claims lacked merit.
Hunegs could not be reached for comment. But in my conversations with him about the case, he had been very confident that Williams would win the case.
There is little question that Smith had serious conversations with Williams about the job, and Williams informed many friends that he had the job. Williams had been very excited about the opportunity to return to Minnesota because he has family here and he had been looking for a place to live here. Rest assured, this case isn't over. You would have to believe that Williams' attorneys will appeal the case, especially after the judge said it was brought to the wrong court.