Ask Eric: What’s a fair share?

Divorcee’s income has soared while ex’s remains the same.

Chicago Tribune
April 6, 2025 at 8:59AM

Dear Eric: My ex-husband and I were on fairly even financial footing when we divorced. Our incomes were similar, and we split the assets down the middle. He was a lazy, selfish, philandering husband. Losing that 200 pounds of deadweight has freed me to focus on advancing my career. My income has doubled, while his has remained relatively stable. He doesn’t know what I make now.

Our child is headed for college this fall. We agreed in the divorce that all of our kid’s expenses would be split evenly. I’ve been saving and have enough for my half of the tuition. However, the kid earned enough in scholarships that I could pay all of the remaining expenses myself. I suspect that even half of the reduced college expenses will be a hardship for my ex.

I have two options: Pay my half, and save whatever is left for the kid’s grad school or first home or whatever launch assist they might need when the time comes. This also enables me to respond to any unanticipated expenses that might arise.

Or I could offer to cover a larger share, even all of it. That will mean less/no money left at the end for easing the transition into adulthood. But it will mean my ex doesn’t have to take out loans (I assume?) to meet his obligation. What are your thoughts?

Eric says: Option A, I beg of you! Thinking through all the angles is kind of you, but we can overstep with kindness, too. Keeping your eyes on your own wallet will be healthiest for you and for the separation.

Secondly, there definitely will be other expenses in your kid’s future. So, having a fund to help ease them into early adulthood will be helpful.

Name the problem

Dear Eric: My sister-in-law cannot seem to get my name right. When I married in 1973, I took my husband’s last name. I went on to have a long teaching career, in which you pretty much just go by “Mrs. Smith.”

My husband died of cancer after 42 years of marriage. Four years later, I found love again and remarried. This time I didn’t change my name. Having been known as “Mrs. Smith” for all those years as an educator, it had become my identity.

I’ve been married to my new husband for almost five years, and I have continued to sign my name on every card, every return address, every document, everything, as “Mary Smith.” But my sister-in-law continues to address cards to me as “Mary Jones.” She has to know that is not my name.

Another birthday card arrived, addressed to “Mary Jones.” How wonderful she remembers my birthday. How annoying that she addresses it to someone that I am not. Do I continue to ignore what has become an irritant, or should I bring it up at some point?

Eric says: Bring! It! Up! It might be an oversight; it might be an intentional slight, but either way it’s not your name. “I’ve noticed you address me as Mary Jones, but I didn’t take husband’s name. The love is the same, no matter the name.” Your name is your name, and she can learn it.

Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@askingeric.com or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110.

about the writer

about the writer

R. Eric Thomas